I've been studying with a JW for a short time. I started searching the internet for more information because much of what she was saying and what I was reading made sense, but I didn't trust my own judgment. I haven't seen the ugliness that I read about here and as an outsider, it looks comforting. I don't have any formed religious beliefs, so she's really working with a blank canvas.
I'm not at a place where I can honestly believe that the bible is *inspired* so it's all very hypothetical: IF the bible is truly the word of God, is what they're telling me accurate? I tried to read the 607/539 (538?) thread, but frankly found it hard to follow. I read about Isaiah prophesying the fall of Babylon, then found arguments that the latter part of Isaiah was written AFTER the fall... but the arguments were not well formed, so I'm left more confused. The arguments against evolution seem flawed because their definition of evolution is so limited - they don't seem to deny adaptation and natural selection as legitimate mechanisms. But hell -- I haven't seen evidence of a change from one species to another. Darwin's finches are still finches, those peppered moths are different, but still moths. What are the explanations for homo habilis, erectus, etc? Other species (not related to humans) that died off?
I'm still coming here to see the Devil's Advocates, as it were -- to discover the questions that I want to ask, that I haven't been able to form. I don't have anyone to talk to about this - I've felt tremendously conflicted for the last several weeks.