WOW!!! I am overwhelmed, excited, exhiliarated, by this thread!! I was an occasional lurker on this site for a few months, maybe years I am not sure. I just started reading again a couple of weeks ago and posted to a few things. This however, is something else! I just finished reading the entire thread (took me 2 days)
Quandry said: "Now hubbie wanted to delete himself as an elder. He did not feel as though these men were loving. He also said that the P.O. was an unfeeling man. I tried to tell him that he was needed, as the one that I knew would do everything in his power to help people and be their advocate. He said he was getting burned out and I could see it."
I totally understand this. This happened to us.
My husband and I were JWs for over 50 years. There were a few things that happened that gave us pause (for a few moments) but for the most part, we believed that the WT was Jehovah's Spirit-directed organization. Right around 1981 a lot of things happened in our congregation that started us thinking that something was wrong and my husband, who had been an Elder (servant) since 1947 began to have doubts that being in that position was beneficial to him and to the brothers. He felt helpless to really help some who were going through some tough things. He felt hog-tied by the WT and the congregation rules. The final straw came sometime during that year (I do not remember what month he stepped down). He said that after stepping down as an Elder, he began to see the hypocrisy in the year text that was above the podium (not sure what it was, but it was about love) He said that he began to see that the decisions that the Elders were making were not about love, but about keeping the rules of the organization intact. We continued to stay in the organization however (It takes a long time for some of us to get to the point of leaving something that has been your total life for so long) What finally happened was that a sister in the congregation told us that when she became a JW they told her that they would study the Bible with her and that they never had. She wanted to take the Bible and with no other study aid just read it and talk about it. My husband said: We can do that. After several weeks, we came to the scripture in Luke 11:11-13 where it says that "God will give holy spirit to those asking". We were reading from the New World Translation. If anyone thinks that you cannot get the truth from that translation, they are wrong. After reading that, sometime later I read an article in Newsweek (I think) about Ray Franz and those who were leaving the WT and somewhere in that article (I thought it was a big issue, but in going back and reading the article, I could hardly find it) it said that these people were saying that the "great crowd" was in heaven. This was a shock to me. I believed, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that they were wrong. I recalled that I had read in the Bible, that I could ask for Holy Spirit, so I did. I asked HS to show me the truth, just as Bro. Russell had asked and been shown. I believed that I would find out that the JWs had the truth. Praying, I began to read the Kingdom Interlinear Translation, checking the Greek when I had questions. When I finished reading it the first time, I was confused. It seemed that there was no concrete proof that there were two groups. Where did I miss it? I read it again! This time I was sure that I could not prove that the great crowd was on earth, in fact it looked like they were in "God's temple" "in sight of the throne". So I read it a third time and began to research the Greek word for "temple". When I finished, I was angry because in the foreword of the KIT they said they would use "one English word to translate each Greek word" and they had lied. I thought if they are not honest about this, what else have they lied about. It was the beginning of my journey out and when I shared it with my hubby he could see it too. He was about 3 months behind me in leaving. I am grateful for that.(that he came out too) However, I heard from my DIL that they said I was the Jezebel that took my family "out of the truth". (my three daughters left also) While we were JWs I did not hear about any of the judicial committees that my husband sat on. He followed the rule that brothers should not tell their wives about what went on. But many times I could tell that he was disturbed by what went on. I later found out that he had a hard time judging adversely some of the things because it seemed to him that the evidince was not conclusive, but the others wanted to disfellowship anyway and sometimes he felt compelled to go along. As time went on, he said it got harder and toward the last, he would abstain from voting, even though pressured to go along. There is a lot of emotional decisions that Elders are called on to make and sometimes, if they have a heart for their brothers and truth, they are hard. Some Elders apparently are able to make these decisions without remorse, but others cannot. I hear the concerns of the Elders who are posting and I know how hard it is for them to make the decision to leave or stay. It is not a decision that can be made lightly. My advice, from what I have learned is this: Ask for Holy Spirit to guide you. God will put in your heart the right thing for you to do. If He wants you out, you will not be able to stay. I wanted to, because of my son and his family and for my mom and my sister and her family, but I just could not. I began to feel sick to my stomach at the meetings, so I just stopped going. I went to my last meeting, the Memorial in April, 1983. This is a serious and personal decision. No one can make it for you. I feel bad that some feel they have to drag others out.
AuldSoul said: "I have been asked many times why I left, and all I can come up with is the questions that I had even though they didn't seem to convey the real reason for my leaving. It wasn't the questions that caused me to leave. It was the insight I gained into how the organization really works, through the process of trying to get my questions answered, that caused me to leave."
I think this says it well. It is not only the questions that were asked, but the inability of the Elders to answer them or the unkind way they did that worked together to leading us out of the organization.
I was privileged to hear so much insight in this thread. I was also glad to see the love and understanding extended to those who are in this quandary to "leave or not leave". We need to extend UNCONDITIONAL love to one another. We should not condemn, just encourage each one in whatever circumstances they are in.
With much love for each one of you,
Velta
Our story: www.geocities.com/veliveleth