I honestly don't know what to make of this.
This is cognitive dissonance at work .. it seems an impossible situation even for OP
Leon Festinger in 1954 to describe “the feeling of psychological discomfort produced by the combined presence of two thoughts that do not follow from one another. Festinger proposed that the greater the discomfort, the greater the desire to reduce the dissonance of the two cognitive elements” (Harmon-Jones & Mills, 1999)
Flipper, you are able peel back the onion and see each layer of a Witness life for what it is. Name callers or hecklers are no different from any brainwashed or inexperienced human. Lacking the insights into the dynamics of the Organization, since they never experienced pride or arrogance on this scale, it's easy to close your eyes and plug your ears and yell "Lah Lah lah lah lah!" Only two choices are really valid, I can walk away from the Organization and have dignity and rebuild my conscience and loose all my friends and family. My second option comes with more benefits, pretend to love Jehovah and my brothers and bask in all the honor and praise, privileges, "demos, parts on the Circuit and District Assembly", "Invitations to International Conventions". I am honest enough to admit, I am only a cog in the Watchtower's wheel, I never claimed to be a lowly follower of Christ
"example can be seen in many people’s continuing to smoke two or three packs of cigarettes a day, even though research shows they are shortening their own lives. They answer this cognitive dissonance with thoughts like, “Well, I’ve tried to quit and it’s just too hard,” or “It’s not as bad as they say and besides, I really enjoy smoking.” Daily smokers justify their behaviors through rationalizations or denial, just as most people do when faced with cognitive dissonance. Things are not right but at least you have the satisfaction of some momentary pleasure and relief"
(quote but lost the source)
You fight everything and everyone because of the greater inner battle being fought right in your own mind !
You can either suffer in silence or lash out for some momentary relief... of your life's contradictions
Socrates extolled that “An unexamined life is not worth living.” ..a sense of hopelessness sets in & self flagellation
Outward heckling is numbed because of the inward raging battle of anger and lack inward peace and control..
you may even welcome punishment as deserved
self-flagellation - self-punishment inflicted by whipping
self-punishment - punishment inflicted on yourself beating with a whip or strap or rope as a form of punishment
self-flag·el·la·tion (s lf fl j -l sh n). n. 1. The act of severely criticizing oneself. 2. The act of punishing oneself.
Not all cries for understanding can "make sense"
I can only ask myself .......should I seek to silence the loudest cries for help ?