I guess what I was trying to say Comf was do you care wether he slept with her or not??? do you disagree with pre-martial sex now??? I know you don't.
Do I care whether FredHall is really a JW or not?
Do I care whether Prisca understands my words or not?
Do I care whether AlanF is viewed as a god or an asshole or both?
When I'm on this board, Vennie, it is the matters on this board that occupy my mind. I post here because I enjoy good repartee with people from backgrounds similar to mine. None of this stuff is of overriding importance to me; I have a wonderful life completely separate from jw.com. But when I'm here, the things that take place here are what I think about.
Here's a new guy, telling a long, detailed story by way of introduction. The story doesn't hold together well. He obviously intends to stay here and be active with us, so I figure I'll ask him about those holes in his story. I do so in a calm, matter-of-fact manner with no insults. I'm careful to repeat over and over throughout the thread that I am not making any judgments, just asking for clarification.
Did he rape her?? I don't know. if he did do you think he'd tell us No. So why get so involved in it?
Because getting involved in it is what we do here. We talk, we exchange ideas and views, we fellowship. If this guy came up to a group of my fellow workers on the job, introduced himself as a new worker, and then offered something like this for us to consider, I would respond exactly as I have here on this board: by pointing out an inconsistency in what he said and asking for clarification.
No, ultimately I don't care about what really happened at the girl's house. What I DO care about is whether somebody is bullshitting me and my friends or not--regardless of the topic. Because if he'll come in and introduce himself with a line of bullshit then you better believe, everything he says is going to be bullshit. You're content to wait a while and gradually figure out that you've been had. I'm not. When I see the signs, I ask about them right off. I can accept your apathy. Please accept my concern.
I think you guys are just a little to shook up from the AlanF wars right now. You're reading my posts, but you're still hearing attitudes from all that. You need to realize that I am not attacking this guy in any way. I'm making conversation. I'm asking questions about what he posted. I'm trying to get a clearer picture on something that disturbed me in what he said.
That's what we do, here, Vennie. We make conversation, and we comment on things others say and ask questions.
I just didn't want to see this thread head that way too. there's no need for it!!!
No problem. All he has to do is give good, reasonable, straight answers to my questions.
I do like to give people the benfit of the doubt and I don't feel the need to expose others flaws.
I give people the benefit of the doubt, too. I haven't come to any conclusions about him. I asked for an explanation.
I guess I wear my heart on my sleave, and just wan't to be honest
And do you expect honesty in return for your honesty?
I must say I'm impressed and pleased at how Prisca and Comf where able to resolve this thread
I am, too. It was a shocker, wasn't it. As I have stated before, I respond to people according to their choices. She could have chosen to prolong the head-butting and I would have kept on with her bout it. It was entirely in her hands, which way our discussion went, and she made a mature, insightful choice, much to my delight.
Maybe Jason will, too, eh?
COMF