To be honest, I have no idea how the appeal of the "Judicial Action" works.
(It seemed any time I had a question the Elders couldn't answer immediately, namely my beard, it took 2-3 weeks for them to come up with an answer. But looking back, perhaps it was those 2-3 weeks they needed to see if there was any wrongdoing by me to perhaps have a little "Judicial" meeting for. Could you imagine being disfellowshipped for wearing a beard?)
Okay, they disfellowship a person, is it immediately told to the congregation? OR... Do they hold back informing the congregation of the decision until after the appeal is heard and decided?
I would hate to think Jehovah's clean congregation would put up with potential fouling of the air.
But then again with Jehovah's spirit on the "Judicial" matter, why would they need an appeal process in the first place? Isn't Jehovah's spirit as perfect as Jehovah himself? But wait! Is the spirit that Jehovah uses in "Judicial matters" the same spirit that directs the writing and publications Watchtower makes? If that's the case, no wonder an appeal process is needed. It is a wonder there isn't several appeals needed, each one overturning the previous judgement!
So many questions... so few answers...