The whole concept of perfection joined with free will is impossible for me to accept. If everyone is perfect (and cannot) sin then how in the world is there any free will.
For example, if Adam and Eve had not sinned then they would be in theory living today. But along the line some of their offspring would have sinned, even down to this day. So what happens? Do they die off slowly while everyone else stays young?
Same would hold true in JW paradise. Their take is that after 1000 years everyone left is perfect, but they still have free will. So after say 100,000,000,000 years of growing carrots and petting pandas, at least a few of them are gonna say "Screw it" and start having sex outside of WT rules right? Then what? Time to start killing them off too?
I enjoyed your questions....all valid points that no JW could honestly answer.