For me... It was the fact that I never joined a "religion" which made me sign up as one of Jehovah's Witnesses.
I was always taught to avoid labels. That my faith was an active declaration of my following of Jesus Christ as the Son of the Living Almighty God, Jehovah.
Since he doesn't walk the Earth, some 2000 years on, I conclude that no one group of people can claim to follow him correctly.
However, if I could turn back time and live in the Middle East... I would sign up immediately, and would be a follower.
I was NEVER, a Jehovah's Witness in the canned and shelved state.
The WT has lost its direction, and even changed the dedication vows to suit its Authoritarian, Legalistic and sadlly "Labelled" Status.
I stand on the sidelines in the "Sin" bin as we Rugby lovers call it.