Gillies Gray writes:
The only valid reason to believe something is true is when there is sufficient evidence to support the claim.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
The burden of proof to back up the assertion that a group of religious leaders were appointed by a supernatural being, second only to the Almighty Himself, would be astronomical. The evidence required would need to be of the highest order.
As things stand, Jehovah’s Witnesses lack valid arguments for the assertion that the Governing Body was ever appointed by Jesus. The best they have is extremely weak abductive reasoning which fails to demonstrate the claim.
Contrast the Governing Body with the examples of God’s appointed representatives found in the bible, all of whom had some kind of extraordinary supernatural verification for their divine appointment. There is not one example of a true representative who was not in direct communication with God or His son.
The claim that the Governing Body were appointed by Jesus is a baseless assertion motivated by mere wishful thinking.