Quentin- hypothetical situation here: a series of events occured when i spilled my glass of water today. my dad left a dog toy on the floor right in my path. i tripped, spilling my water all over the floor. i happened to notice an ant drowned in my spilt water. this ant's life was taken. hypothetically, if ants were conscious beings, as are humans, could you imagine this ant's family torturing themselves by asking "why did little cleatus have to die? why?!" was there some higher being who wanted to take this ants life? no, it was simply a mistake on my part for not watching where i was walking (or you could place blame on my dad for not setting the toy aside.lol i like that idea better) "why" seems to me like the wrong question to ask. why does there even have to be a reason why? can't it just be?
"why is the sky blue?" reactions of atoms and light in the atmosphere, etc. "well who decided to make it blue?" this is where these types of questions veer off the path of logic. where is this "who" coming from? i guess its understandable that we're all use to seeing things, like a chair, and just having the common sense that the chair could not be in existance unless some "who" created it. so i guess its easy to apply that line of thought to everything (life-death situations, the universe, etc). it may make sense to apply the "if theres a creature, there must be a creator" type thinking to physical things, but when your dealing with the realm of intangibles, its quite different. you should only go by what you know, as already posted by someone else.
"why" questions just seem ridiculous to me. if you want to start asking why questions, then why not do it for everything? why was my car painted white? who decided to paint my car white? is it b/c white cars are the safest and God wants me to survive and drive safely? or maybe it was just b/c they were all out of all the other colors. most ppl would like to believe the reason why would be b/c "white cars are the safest and God wants me to survive and drive safely." that sounds more comforting, yea i think i like that, thats what im gonn believe. im special and God wants me alive. its a mechanism the human brain has in order to cope with their fear of death. other organisms don't have a fear of death, since they are not conscious beings like us.