To Bijou,
To answer your question, yes I'd question it and them. If you decide for what ever reason to give your kid(s)away, it shoudn't matter what religion they are in as long as the home and parent(s) are stable, loving, will accept the kid(s) regardless to what religion or background they came from. Don't get me wrong, I know a single widowed JW female who took in foster kids and adoped kids. These kids didn't come from JW homes and she still provided a home for them. And by the way, these kids were in age range 10-16 years of age when she brought them into her home. Yes she introduced them to the religion, they attended the meetings and assembly's but she also assured them that even if they chose not to be witnesses or even study, she wouldn't treat them any different and doesn't. She loves them uncondionally and she treats them like their her blood, not like there were adopted or abandoned. Yes, JW set a high standard of living, just like anyone should but I've never come across any JW who shunned their own family just because they chose not to be a JW, if they do, there's something very deep going on that nobody knows about.