Utah, huh?
Know what I think?
Ten bucks says the previous court's decision was influenced by the Mormon Church (I can't believe they wouldn't have had a vested interest in keeping church discipline internal)...
...and that one of the reasons the appeal is now being reconsidered is because a few key people found out, and were able to positively influence the courts behind the scenes in exchange for keeping that troublesome info on the down-low.
Seriously.
Know why?
'Cause it wouldn't be the first time something similar happened.
A few years back, the LDS was the secret driving force behind Proposition 8 in California, and when that was exposed, not only was the original ruling overturned, but they were very publicly embarrassed...
...and I find it very hard to believe that they're eager to get nailed for pushing too hard against the church-state wall like that again so soon.