mindfield, I totally know where you are coming from. I'm sure I'd still be "in" (been out 20 yrs) if it weren't for my inability to line up witness behavior with what they preach. We got "in" when we were young adults - prior to that we'd gotten along just fine. After two or three years "in the truth", we were tearing at each others throats. One of my brothers put a suit on one SAturday afternoon, so he could make an official APPROACH to my other brother about some silly little incident, that normal families deal with over a beer!
The derogertory (sp?) comments my brother's new wife made about others used to shock me - coz she was from one of the most favoured spiritual families in our city. I used to sit there doing mental gymnastics trying to work out what was happening.
I suppose the likes of you and I idealise a religion like the JWs. We just expect them to practise what they preach. The bottom line is that they are no better than any other small group, religious or otherwise.
best wishes
Marilyn