I agree with Chooks original post and with all the other posts but I have a question...
The Society states in the Elders handbook that an elder guilty of serious wrongdoing in the past does not have to step down (which would include not being handled judicially since that would mean stepping down) from his position IF he is still viewed favorably by the community and congregation.
This statement was also in an obscure Kingdom Ministry used as a reference in the Elders manual.
So wouldnt that be their "out" on this idea of invalidating an elders judicial rulings because of his own personal wrongdoing?
And good for that elder above that stepped down on his own and admitted his "hidden sin". At least he had the ability to do that. If more elders were that honest the elder body would be diminished by at least 3/4 its current size.