Where the hell does Jesus say the lives of these certain ones would overlap one another ?
I'm I missing something here ?
What I read out of Jesus's words that once the signs of the end times began the generation that witnessed those apparent signs would not
pass away. Anointed or not anointed ! Where they pulled this overlapping generation(s) is made up wholly by themselves.
it seems to me that this "overlapping generation" is less of a lame WTS exegesis as it just a building on top of other generation teachings.
To JW's this would be easily absorbed because they already accept that the generation is 'anointed' so no problems there, and they already accept that the signs began in 1914 so no problem there either.
And how many times have we heard the word "contemporanious" used with the generation? This goes all the way back to Russel and right up to the 'contemporanious wicked' generation.
so the generation is not "generations" but rather one "contemporanious generation".
"This all sounds so familiar, this really isn't all that different is it?" To the longtime JW this is not all that much of stretch, but of course to us and anyone with an objective viewpoint we are dumbfounded that anyone could possibly believe such insane rhetoric.
I have always wondered why the reasoning book never update the generation from that of 1914. Well, (as I have said before) I suppose now they don't really need to. The generation today IS STILL the generation of 1914. That is exactly the same.The change is the definition what a generation is.
For all intents and purposes, the reasoning book is now correct again. They need only ad a footnote clarifying that 'generation' is a 'contemporanious generation' and it is this "contemporanious generation" that saw 1914 that will by no means pass away, 'just like we always said.'