@ notsurewheretogo - a close friend insisted that independence was the best thing for Scotland. I asked him how I would be better off financially and in other ways. No definitive answers - but claimed every country who gained independence was far better off.
I'd vote for an independent Scotland - if undeniable benefits were offered which overwhelmed the serious consequences it would cause, but the SNP hasn't and can't genuinely answer the huge questions which will/could threaten people's livelihoods.
Leaving a union causes serious downsides to the working classes. Brexit still isn't over - and as far as I can see, there have been no significant benefits to the UK.