Posts by WhatshallIcallmyself

60

Can someone tell me why Joan's ark and the flood not true and impossible?

by Gokumonkey in

hey everyone.

i have a question and i hope i'm not confusing this with something else i heard.

while watching ex jw videos on youtube many of them talk about how noah's ark and the flood didn't happen and it's impossible.

WhatshallIcallmyself

Geology tells us all we need to know about the possibility of a global flood. The good thing about that branch of science with regards to this topic is that whatever is asserted by those that believe a worldwide flood happened can be readily checked with our evidence. That alone allows you to forget about how animals got to this ark and how this ark was built etc.

http://talkorigins.org/origins/faqs-flood.html

However that is a complicated subject that takes time to learn and understand. So instead focus on the contemporary civilisations around the world that make no mention of a global flood (or getting wiped out) and continue with their progression oblivious to this supposed event. Google will throw up all manner of information about societies alive at the time this flood was meant to have happened...

40

Difficulty fading out

by Emily1987 in

jw
friends

this is my first post on here so i apologize that it is like an essay!.

my husband and i are currently 'fading out' of the truth.

we stopped preaching in may 2016 and limited meeting attendance in january 2017 and stopped completely in june 2017. my main reason for this was my whole life i have been doing things to please others, even getting baptized to please my mum.

WhatshallIcallmyself

Any contact from the local Jws from now on isn't going to be for your 'spiritual' welfare but to sow fear into those remaining in the congregation that you have left.

Other posters have mentioned F.O.G. on here and the elders will try their hardest to ensure you are made an example of, if you let them, to ensure a fear of isolation is put into those who may also feel they can fade away; to remind them that they are obliged to tell on their brothers and sisters if they see anything untoward happening; and to remind them that continuing to be your friend would make god cry...

If you want to be party to their F.O.G tactics then meet with them. If you want no further part in their cult then tell them to F.O.!

18

God is our help, not “a burden”

by venus in

sir julian huxley (one of the great pillars of modern neo-darwinism) may be a symbol of people who feel god is a burden because he wrote: “the god hypothesis .

is becoming an intellectual and moral burden on our thought.

" therefore, he concluded that "we must construct something to take its place.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"This is not the time to argue" - venus

I saw no evidence of argumentation; if there were, that would suggest both of your views were equally valid which they are not. What I saw was cofty schooling you on your ignorance of evolution via natural selection.

35

Bible is good if we look for implied truth

by venus in

thumbs-up gesture doesn’t covey much if we see only four fingers closed and thumb standing upward.

but if we look for the implied meaning, then it is a positive, informal signal indicating a job well done, and saying ‘keep it up.’.

similarly, biblical accounts don’t convey much if we see them as mere accounts.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"In the realm of spiritual physics" - venus

What on Earth is that then? Define what that is. How can we test the claims you are making.

Or are you simply hijacking scientific sounding words to bolster some ludicrous idea?

"When I reminded you about the impropriety of using “fuck off” towards a lady" - venus

Your gender is irrelevant. What you are asking for is in itself is a product of an archaic notion that females should be held to a different standard than their male counterparts. Logically therefore it is you that are living like an 'iron age' throwback and not Cofty who is treating you equally to everyone else who spouts new-age nonsense.

Your comments about evolution only shows your ignorance of the subject, it certainly does not support your attempted point...sigh.

102

If mathematics teacher made a mistake, would it mean mathematics itself is wrong!

by venus in

many people point to the irrationality in the depiction of god by the religions and their scriptures, hence jump into the bottomless pit of atheism.

in either camp, god is not a factor because religion is only a means that misrepresents god, hence religionists themselves are atheists (literally, those who live without god).

it is like saying there exists no earth because you found out your friend who taught earth is flat is wrong; or it is like saying mathematics itself is wrong because you found out your mathematics teacher made a mistake.

WhatshallIcallmyself

Prove a god exists... You cannot...

Define what a god is... You cannot...

If a god exists and you cannot define/prove it then it might as well not exist for all the good it does us.

We know maths exists because we can use it to quantify observations of our environment. This is testable and has a proven track record of accuracy. We also know the Earth is not flat because we can see it isn't. It does not matter what some people may or may not say about it.

You're analogies are awful and have no bearing on what you are trying to prove. You might find your time is better spent elsewhere...

35

Bible is good if we look for implied truth

by venus in

thumbs-up gesture doesn’t covey much if we see only four fingers closed and thumb standing upward.

but if we look for the implied meaning, then it is a positive, informal signal indicating a job well done, and saying ‘keep it up.’.

similarly, biblical accounts don’t convey much if we see them as mere accounts.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"atheists and agnostics think of themselves as more open-minded than those of a religious bent, but are actually less tolerant to differing opinions and ideas" - venus

When you believe in and preach bollocks it is harder to be intolerant to other bollocks because the same arguments you would use against their bollocks would also apply to yours. Therefore it is better to tolerate another's bollocks lest attention is drawn to your own...

Atheists and agnostics on the other hand don't have to worry about defending bollocks and are therefore in a better position to call the bollocks believer to account.

Also, I think a stone age man would probably also tell you to fuck off, as I doubt they were dumb enough to accept your nonsense...

31

Big xJW scandal

by Charlotte in

.

WhatshallIcallmyself

If people have evidence of a crime then report it to the authorities. If you don't have evidence then shut the fk up. I'm getting really fked off with these "hashtag warriors" who think it is fine to throw around accusations and that "social justice" trumps the justice system.

Real crimes are being watered down in people's minds due to this type of behaviour. Women and men who are victims are finding it harder to get this behaviour taken seriously due to the amount of 'crime' being revealed online.

A fine example of this is the social media channel being used by members of staff at the English Parliament to complain of sexual abuse whilst at work; yet where are the complaints to the police?

People, quite rightly, are beginning to treat these things as bandwagon complaints from attention seeking idiots.

Charlotte, you can take your first post and #stickitwherethesundontshine

26

Darwin's lack of evidence

by Half banana in

while making bread this morning and between answering the door and phone calls, i listened on steam radio to the programme in our time with melvyn bragg.

his panel of experts explained how the discovery of thousands of bird fossils has revolutionised our perception of avian evolution.

i recall watchtower literature smugly presenting darwin’s admissions in his origin of the species that the geological evidence for bird evolution is “imperfect” in fact missing.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"Maybe. But don't confuse evidence with interpretation and conclusions." - Fisherman

Shouldn't you learn about the subject you so like to belittle before attempting to offer your opinion on it?

In your world "god did it" may be an easy explanation but out here in reality that answers nothing and helps no one.

50

The wonder of scientific research

by amicabl in

this has possibly been brought up before however here goes.. constant reference is made by many posters to scientific research as being the only way to prove something factual that would otherwise have to be taken on faith.

there actually seems to be "faith" in scientific findings.. my experience over many years is that most scientific research is fake.

nothing oftencomes of the big announcements made to raise more money.. money, prestige, pride, human error, suppositions etc., are rife amongst the scientific community.. i realise that there have been many advances over hundreds of years but humankind is in a mess, although very different to even a century ago.. the medical profession now has vaccinations for everything, antiviral drugs etc.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"I was in hospital for 24 days mostly because they couldn't find a suitable blood thinner for me. Really?" - amicabl

Blood clots to the brain are super cool; they should have let you out early.

And who needs prostate exams? It's all just hyped up nonsense to make money for those scheming doctors.

JWs often argue that science education isn't necessary because "who do you know that makes use of their science education in their everyday jobs".

I think amecabl is a good example of why science education is important.

33

Using history as a means to pinpoint possible future events.

by HealthySkeptic in

the purpose of this thread is to share some history with the community.

i am an active jw.

the reason i picked this forum is due to the openness and ease with which information can be accessed.

WhatshallIcallmyself

"Gene Roddenberry the creator of the Star Trek series talked to these other worldly beings through spiritistic means and got some of his ideas that he would later use in Star Trek. They identified themselves as the council of nine or the Ennead of ancient Egypt" - (un-?)hs

What has to happen to someone in order for them to actually believe this silliness? Still, for entertainment value, these few posts of unHealthySkeptic have been interesting.