I was an elder a long time, and we did very well not talking out of turn.
True it's not foolproof, and some people like to show they are big shots about what they know.
I think what happens more often is that people put 2 and 2 together and think someone f#cked around. And that's true 90% of the time.
Don't get me wrong - JWs are the BIGGEST Gossip Whores you will ever find.
I have experience that to a large degree after fading
Hey ttdtt
Thanks for your comment. There is a lot of truth in what you say. I don't doubt the sincerity of many elders as confidentiality is a must. However. Having experienced the star chamber myself, I can only say that my experience felt like an interrogation. I also felt that it was very intrusive. The questions asked of me were unbelievable. Having been through a JD in the past has been really off putting. Matters should be kept private. No one else's business. Announcing that someone has been reproved before the whole congregation for a one off sin is disgusting and wrong. It flies in the face of scripture. The GB have their policies upside down. They need to read their bibles and get it right.