Circular reasoning. Very bizarre.
Insight on the Scriptures is littered with circular reasoning. Their whole foundation is logical fallacy.
Not much of a rock to build on, is it?
schnell
JoinedPosts by schnell
-
46
If You Could Ask the GB Or One Of Its Members...
by Cold Steel in...one question about anything and get a straight answer, what would it be?
historical, philosophical, theological, eschatological, anything.
.
-
-
schnell
-
9
Hey, remember when Family Guy had a Watchtower?
by schnell inhey, remember that one time on family guy when the evil monkey in chris's closet became a jw?.
i remember thinking, pssht, they'd never do that.. hey, remember when they did it?.
i am dying to know if someone awake at bethel in the art department or whatever saw that episode and recommended this cover a few years ago.
-
-
schnell
That's a classic too!
-
9
Hey, remember when Family Guy had a Watchtower?
by schnell inhey, remember that one time on family guy when the evil monkey in chris's closet became a jw?.
i remember thinking, pssht, they'd never do that.. hey, remember when they did it?.
i am dying to know if someone awake at bethel in the art department or whatever saw that episode and recommended this cover a few years ago.
-
-
schnell
Ha! Well, if this is what we're doing, you can't beat a classic:
-
-
-
schnell
Ehud is my personal favorite.
-
"There is a friend for everyone in the corporation's clutches"
by schnell in"there is a friend for everyone in the corporation's clutches" -- brokeback watchtower.
i just needed to make a separate thread about this.. forced friends are not friends.
as the great marvin gaye said, "smiling faces tell lies.
-
schnell
"There is a friend for everyone in the corporation's clutches" -- Brokeback Watchtower
I just needed to make a separate thread about this.
Forced friends are not friends. As the great Marvin Gaye said, "Smiling faces tell lies." Once you discover that without belief in the Watchtower, you don't actually have much in common and cannot stand the untenable arguments of your old "friends", it's really over.
Once you understand that the congregation's political correctness requires forgiveness even of pedophiles and criminals, you're really forced to square a circle and possibly put yourself or others at risk.
No, thank you. If that is "love" to anyone else, you can keep it.
-
14
They Offered Their Son Willingly—To Bethelite Brothers
by betterdaze inthey offered themselves willingly—in new yorkricky, a construction project manager in hawaii, was invited to serve as a commuter bethelite to assist with the warwick project.
his wife, kendra, wanted him to accept the invitation.
however, they had a legitimate concern: the welfare of their 11-year-old son, jacob.
-
-
schnell
It is truly amazing how blind someone can be to what's going on. Also, the comments have not been ridiculous, though ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible propositions.
:)
-
39
How do you feel about the expression "The Truth"?
by stuckinarut2 init's amazing how the expression "the truth" has become such an ingrained term used by witnesses.. "we have 'the truth'".
"is he 'in the truth'?".
most here have found out so many facts about the organisation, and felt the effects of being "gut-punched" as we realised these facts.. so how do you feel about the expression "the truth" now?.
-
-
schnell
what is truth?
Hey there, Pontius, wash your mouth out after your hands. 😉
Yes, and to add to your list, mathematicians talk about proof. That's another word that JWs and Bible literalists seem to not understand. Their proof is most often circular reasoning and the logical fallacy that if someone said so then it must be true.
Truth to me is a theory that gives consistent results. I can trust that if I lean up against a giant redwood, it won't fall down. I can trust that if I ignore a mechanical problem, it will not go away. I can trust that if I have 2 of something and you give me 3 more, I will then have 5 of something. I can also trust that if the laws of physics changed at some point in the last 6000 years so as to compromise radiometric dating, then there must be very good physical and mathematical evidence of it.
Hell, I can even trust that if I am only a brain in a vat being fed a simulation of a world around me, that it doesn't matter because this might as well be the real thing. For all intents and purposes and due to consistent results, it is the real thing. If I had a cat, she could view me as a slave and have a whole mythological perception in her head about her little world, too, but I'd still be the one holding her food.
-
101
Are Gods true worshippers on Earth today? If they are not JWs then who are they?
by Formerbrother inis there gods true worshipers on earth today as jesus said there would be?
if they are not jws then who are they?.
who else comes close to being gods true followers today?.
-
-
schnell
In my opinion, the whole "where else to go?" question actually results from a lack of understanding of christianity.
I agree. This is why I love people like Bart Ehrman. His books have been a real eye opener for me about the development of Christianity.
Ken "You Weren't There" Ham has shown me how similar JW arguments about the natural world have been to the young earth creationism they claim to disavow.
-
37
Has the rebranding worked?
by MrTheocratic init's been several years since the start of the rebranding of jehovahs witnesses.
i believe it started with the website change.
ever since then the religion has moved in a more modern direction.
-
-
schnell
Doc, oh god, that pig, I just saw that first Black Mirror episode and it's too soon lol
-
9
Hey, remember when Family Guy had a Watchtower?
by schnell inhey, remember that one time on family guy when the evil monkey in chris's closet became a jw?.
i remember thinking, pssht, they'd never do that.. hey, remember when they did it?.
i am dying to know if someone awake at bethel in the art department or whatever saw that episode and recommended this cover a few years ago.
-
-
schnell
The Weezer album death to false metal is super funny. I would sure love to hear the story behind it. The funny part is I bet 98 percent of the public doesn't get it.
That is hilarious!