Comf,
First of all, I appreciate your input and value your opinion. I often use the word "argue" inappropriately, since a lively discussion gets defined as "argument" in my world.
As far as the "reality" argument, we are never going to agree. You say that none of us can know reality because of our perceptive filters - THAT we do agree on. Then, you say that there is a reality which prevents spells from 'working':
Likewise for praying, and for spells or rituals intended to produce a change in something outside ourselves. They don't work. That's the reality.
To me, that is a contradiction. We don't know what reality really is, but the reality that we don't understand stops spells from working. (?)
On the websites:
Of course it's representative of pagans. Who says you're the one who gets to define pagan?
Fair enough, you make a good point here. It is representative of SOME pagans. Remember that its only SOME and that the beliefs of pagans vary widely. You use these websites as some sort of evidence and generalise to say that it represents the pagan community as a whole. That is wrong.
Plus, you keep on confusing Wicca with pagans:
You seem to be confusing pagans with people who make money from trying to sell "spells" to people.I've done enough research on wicca to know that a great deal of it has to do with ritual and spell-casting
WICCA does have a lot to do with ritual and spellcasting. (Although some wiccans never spellcast). PAGANISM is often not about spells at all and some pagans don't use ritual in the same way either.
Now onto the "does magick work?" question. Remember the context of my comments about it. You asserted that ritual /spells were
Belief in unseen forces that you can control by standing a certain way at a certain time and chanting certain words while holding certain objects.
I replied to say that if YOU try to do the above (stand a certain way, etc.) then you will get no results. Why? because spellwork is not about how you stand, or what you chant, or what you hold in your hands. You were reducing a religious practice to a mere 'act'.
I believe that we can affect our reality - just like the website you quoted said.
Of course, I could be wrong. You could be wrong. I'm glad that in this day and age we have such freedom of speech and such diversity that we can have this sort of discussion.
Sirona
** http://www.religioustolerance.org **