THP- i actually found your post very interesting. you haven't made me a believer, but i do have a couple of questions about your theory.
1. if manna was a bunch of mushrooms, specifically magic mushrooms, how did they sustain the isrealites nutritionally? according to the bible, even when there was other food, it was the manna that was their staple.
2. how could the isrealites eat the mushrooms daily for any long period of time? the ritual use of these mushrooms has usually been documented as just that, ritual, not daily. not to mention the fact that when someone takes mushrooms the day after previously taking them, they must eat twice the amount to get the same effect. compile this day after day, and the mushrooms would cease to have the same effect that they did in the first place. also, have you ever heard of anyone who was able to sustain that amount of daily ingestion for very long at all? a couple of, maybe even several days, maybe, but weeks, months, years? i don't know...
THP- i'm not attacking your post, just really curious how you would answer these questions. thanks-unanswered