I may be odd man out on this one. I was born and raised a JW and I've ALWAYS liked Christmas. I agree with not promoting the Santa lie and gimme gimme gimme 'cause you gotta. To me, it was never about the "stuff". It's the smells, the atmosphere, the food, the songs (O Holy Night always gives me the chills), the visits from friends, (most of them JW's) etc;. Did I say, most of them JW's? The hardest part about all this was that I had to keep most of this happiness to myself, appear to be somber in public and "tsk, tsk" everyone who celebrated because I "felt sorry for them" . There were a select few JW's who privately admitted liking Christmas as much as I do. The feeling I get is probably the same feeling that the little Whos (from How the Grinch Stole Christmas) felt when the Grinch stole all the presents and they all joined hands and sang "Fah who for-aze! Dah who dor-aze! Welcome Christmas, Come this way!" They had not presents but the spirit lived on. I like that.