Cappytan,
A lot of us have been on your journey. I've called it my Pink Floyd sojourn - Another Brick in the Wall. I didn't worry about it as you are, however. It was an excellent, rational journey to me. I took my time, removing and evaluating each JW/Christian/Theist brick at a time. If I found it lacking, and I did, I threw it away.
After a few years all that was left was the foundation - a belief in god. I remember referring to myself to my closest friends as an agnostic, then an atheistic leaning agnostic, then an atheist. No drama. No angst. No fears.
Good luck on your journey.