PON said- How was Adam Perfect? It is a void question. He didn't exist..........in my opinion that is.
Well, that's an unsupported CONCLUSION, a thought-stopper. If someone accepts unsupported conclusions, then it would actually be counter-productive to the ultimate goal of getting people to think for themselves, since they'd onlt be accepting the conclusions of others without having any reason to justify the belief.
I mean, yes, you're right, but getting to that point requires coming from within the account, and presupposing it IS true in order to point out the inconsistencies within.
galaxie said-
Hi all ,just a thought , if Satan put a doubt in eves mind who at that time was"perfect "ie is without sin, then who put the doubt in Satan's mind or conciousness if you like after all wasn't he created as a perfect angel? Seems to me it could only have been his creator . Does that not create a circle of thought which can't be squared? Just a thought!!
Yup, that's the question I asked as a 12 y.o. kid, and never received a satisfactory answer to the question. (It, along with 'the problem of evil' convinced me the Bible was all wet.)
If God was "perfect", then where did the conception of imperfection come from, if not created by God?
In other words, how did an angel get the capability to feel envy? And how did Eve possess the capability to "covet" if she was "perfect"?
Flawed products both. God cannot try to pin the blame on what He creates: there's an old German saying, "it's a poor craftsman indeed who blames his tools, or the items he makes, rather than blaming himself for his lack of skill as a craftsman".
It turns out the Jews didn't conceive of Adam and Eve as "perfect" humans, but imperfect beings whom God expected to CONTROL their tendencies to sin ('yetzer hara' in Hebrew). Hence why Jews feel no need to be redeemed for Adamic sin by the blood sacrifice of a "perfect" Jesus: it makes no gobsmacking sense in Jewish theology, but only results from later Xian additions to the Hebraic account (and is sold and swallowed by Gentiles, who don't bother to understand Jewish interpretations of the OT, or to understand the thinking behind the traditions contained inside the Old Testament).
Adam