Hi qcmbr;...The detail you have gone into and the points you make, all have relevancy and great importance to those wishing independence.
The crucial point is as country where should those decisions of governance be made, it's as simple as that.
Your argument would be strengthened if the people of Scotland at the least had by a substantial amount voted for the Westminster gov'.
This has not been the case (only one mp at present )therefore the VAST majority are not represented.
As democracy is the political system by which most agree is the best way of governance, how can anyone deny it's right to self determination.
As I have said the the grumblings of dissent are increasing by the minute, which would have continued even if Scotland had voted yes.
As it is we have to once again wait for a government the Scottish people vastly did not vote for to dole out our lot.
I don't see this as a slight on the rest of the uk , I have many connections which I treasure.
It entirely about democracy. The present and future political wranglings will be of great interest and effect to us all.
Best wishes to you.