I appreciate all the feedback. It seems like I have two main paths to choose from. 1 - I can play the game, turn the tables, and frustrate the brothers who are trying to get some dirt on me. 2 - I can refuse to play, stop worrying about what is going on here, and move on with my life. Number 2 seems to be the healthier choice for me psychologically, but the monkey wrench in that plan is the fact that my wife is active, and so I am unable to completely remove the witnesses from my life. Lately we have been thinking seriously about moving out of state. That way I can have a measure of anonymity, and my wife can go the meetings without being interrogated about me.
It is amazing to me to realize how many people have been tricked into "convicting" themselves by trusted friends and family. I am sorry for everyone who has been hurt in this way.