CHRISTIAN & WICCAN CONFLICTS

by avishai 40 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Benjamin:
    Don't be a condescending fart all your life

    This is what was disagreeable:

    Wiccans are wannabe Christians anyway. They try to act liberated and ancient, but they still tie themselves down with "threefold law" morality which holds them back and makes them just as fearful as Christians are. They also(most of them) think their religion is ancient, when it was based on Gardener's bastardization of Golden Dawn rituals and things he took from Crowley(yet most of them frown upon or dislike Golden Dawn magic and Crowley).

    Gretchen called you on it, and as a practicing pagan she probably has half a clue...

    While you claim that most of them frown on Crowley, you attempt to make a case that their beliefs are based upon his work. You would also appear to support his work by your caricaturisation of the "three-fold law morality". Not many are free-luvvin satanists (meant in a totally non-perjorative sense).

  • Gretchen956
    Gretchen956

    Benjamin,

    Most pagans don't believe in the three-fold law. Some do. Most do believe in this law: If it harms none, do what thou will. That has no cause and effect involved. Some pagans do believe in karma, I do, for instance, but its a very controversial belief within pagans and hotly debated whether it "belongs." As to Crowley, he was the person that brought wicca or paganism to the attention of the public, but I would not say that he is any messiah. Not all pagans even hold to the god and goddess (essential to his belief). As a Dianic pagan I hold to the goddess. Pagans in general are very tolerant people (not all). We don't recruit (proseletyze) nor do we try to tell others what to believe.

    I fail to see the connection with christianity. It seems the only vague connection is a belief in a higher power. As a stretch you could say that christians are wannabe pagans, so many of their beliefs (including many found in the bible) have pagan origins.

    Sherry

  • hamsterbait
    hamsterbait

    i would like it if a person could stand n the background at a seance. What can the circle find out that they didnt know?

    HB

  • Gretchen956
    Gretchen956

    Hamsterbait, sorry we don't do seances. That is spiritism, not wicca and not pagan. I'm sure that some people that do them could be pagan, I don't know, but absolutely has nothing to do with what we're talking about here. Rituals are a form of worship, they aren't used for the purposes that seances are. They are for getting in touch with the Goddess, (and gods for some), and for requests for healing, blessings, etc., much the same as prayer except that we aren't just talking we're involved within a ritual in that we are burning incense, lighting candles, etc., in more of an interactive way.

    Most people have no clue what wicca or earth-based spirituality is, they just go by someone telling them it's satanistic. Satan is a judeo-christian construct, we don't believe he exists let alone worship something that doesn't exist. There are some satanists out there, that is a totally different religion.

    Sherry

  • Benjamin Belial
    Benjamin Belial
    Gretchen called you on it, and as a practicing pagan she probably has half a clue...

    I've been a practicing Pagan for years. What's your point again?

    While you claim that most of them frown on Crowley, you attempt to make a case that their beliefs are based upon his work. ; You would also appear to support his work by your caricaturisation of the "three-fold law morality". ; Not many are free-luvvin satanists (meant in a totally non-perjorative sense).

    Uh... who trained Gardener again?

  • Benjamin Belial
    Benjamin Belial
    Most pagans don't believe in the three-fold law. ; Some do. ; Most do believe in this law: ; If it harms none, do what thou will. ; That has no cause and effect involved. ; Some pagans do believe in karma, I do, for instance, but its a very controversial belief within pagans and hotly debated whether it "belongs." ; As to Crowley, he was the person that brought wicca or paganism to the attention of the public, but I would not say that he is any messiah. ; Not all pagans even hold to the god and goddess (essential to his belief). ; As a Dianic pagan I hold to the goddess. ; Pagans in general are very tolerant people (not all). ; We don't recruit (proseletyze) nor do we try to tell others what to believe.

    As a Pagan I don't see a need for your history lesson, but thanks.

    Nice strawman argument. I never said most Pagans believe in the three-fold law. I said most Wiccans do. You're debating like if someone says Catholics believe something, then all Christians do. I never said that. I said Wiccans, not Pagans.

    And again, for like the fifth time, I didn't say Crowley was a messiah or a Wiccan. Crowley was one of the people who trained Gardener. Gardener learned from Crowley and took rituals from the Golden Dawn and so forth, watered them down, and made them much more simplistic.

    Yeah, I know Pagans don't all believe in "the goddess" because it's more stuff somebody invented. There was no "the goddess" until the last century. I never believed in "the goddess."

    So enough with the history lessons. I'm not stupid or uneducated in this area of knowledge.

    I fail to see the connection with christianity. ; It seems the only vague connection is a belief in a higher power. ; As a stretch you could say that christians are wannabe pagans, so many of their beliefs (including many found in the bible) have pagan origins.

    Yeah, I kind of said that too. How is it that so many people totally missed the entire point of my post so completely?

    Let me dumb it down for you, okay?

    Christians - took beliefs from the Pagans. Dislike/hate Pagans. Acts superior to everyone else. Try to be really moral but do the same dumb stuff everyone else does or worse.

    Wiccans - took beliefs and rituals from Golden Dawn, OTO, Crowley, etc, but in general dislike ceremonial magic and Crowley(in fact, tend to act scared of him). Also tend to act superior(and this is from personal experience, almost every Wiccan I've met has acted arrogant and superior). Try to be more liberal and openminded than Christians, yet are held back by the same sense of morality most of the time.

    You can dispute this all you want, but I've been there, I've seen it. I was building my own Pagan church. I still have the web domain www.churchofpaganunity.org which I gave up on for various reasons. I can give you a link to the original site and you can see what I wrote on the page, the Kemetic flowchart I created, and so on. Kemetic because that's what I was, a Kemetic. (Oh no, a Kemetic judging Wiccans!)

    Does any of this make sense yet or do I have to keep explaining?

  • amommy
    amommy

    Gretchen . If you don't serve our Creator ( Our heavenly God the Almighty and the one whom he sent forth Jesus Christ) might I add who died and spilled his blood for us then you must be from your father the Devil . In the bible we are taught we are either on his side or the Devil's , there is no gray area in that only distractions we as humans create. Now serving him is not Dogmatic and full of rules as most religious groups try to imply. Rather he is kind and patient . He desires all to find. We have to read the bible on our own and Pray .We don't need leaders to tell us how to worship Jesus teaches us in the new testament.

    "Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart,and you will find rest for your souls.For my yoke is easy and my burden is light." Matt. 11:29-30

    This is in my opinion the best offer out there.but hey! that is just my opinion. Agreed that most religion is harsh putting christianity in a bad light. Who gets the tarnished reputation" Jesus Christ" But it is not his fault , so why should we punish him and therefore ultimately ourselves?Study at home, grow to love Christ our Savior on your own. Let no one tear your from God's love!

  • Gretchen956
    Gretchen956

    Benjamin, my bad, I thought I had read pagan, lots of folks use those interchangeably anymore, such as Xerox machine means copier in a generic sense and not a brand except to the company! Your message was cryptic, but we now get your point. In fact I probably get it better than most in that I have run into wiccans such as you describe. IMO anyone who tries to tell you they have the only way is selling snake oil.

    As to the goddess, I believe she was around a lot longer than the bible, at least archeology bears this out (as in "When God Was a Woman" and "The Chalice and the Blade".) However, I am not advocating anyone else believe in her, just that I do.

    amommy, if you think I'm a pagan because I know nothing about christianity you are mistaken. I found my peace, my connection, and my spirituality on another path. I don't expect you to understand it, and I'm not asking for your support or permission. I would not presume to try to change your belief system, its presumptuous of you to try to change mine as well.

    Sherry

  • outnfree
    outnfree

    "Yeah, I know Pagans don't all believe in "the goddess" because it's more stuff somebody invented. There was no "the goddess" until the last century."


    Benjamin,


    Are you saying that Pagans didn't believe in "the goddess" until the last century? Because I'm sure you cannot be saying that there have not been cults who worshipped various goddesses (some would say various facets of "the goddess") for hundreds, if not thousands of years?


    Personally, I have felt the need at various times to think of the One as masculine or feminine, but really, Spirit is neither, is it?


    outnfree

  • Benjamin Belial
    Benjamin Belial

    Though many of the original witches did worship Satan, as did many Wiccans and witches up until the point that LaVey totally embarassed the movement, but you'll rarely find a modern Wiccan who will admit this.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit