American Idol

by Mulan 38 Replies latest social entertainment

• 

  Mulan

  I just thought I would start a new American Idol thread.

  Any comments on this week's shows?

  I thought it was time for Kellie to go. I think she is just a darling girl, but not anywhere in the same league as the ones left now.

  Katherine was so good this week, and I'm glad the judges adjusted their criticism last night. I thought she sounded wonderful and just assumed they didn't hear what we did on TV. Guess I was right.

  Chris was the best. His voice reminds me of Brian Adams, but I think he's so much better than BA. His voice has more to it I think.

  Paris is next to go, I predict. She is really good, but it's time.
• 

  LDH

  thought it was time for Kellie to go. I think she is just a darling girl, but not anywhere in the same league as the ones left now.

  Agree.

  Next should go Paris,

  then Catherine

  then Taylor

  then it should be down to Chris and Elliott, who is my personal favorite.
• 

  kid-A

  My prediction: It will end as a showdown between Catherine and Elliot, and Catherine will take it.

  Catherine is absolutely stunning and has huge star potential. Paris will go next, she's cute, but not much charisma.

  Taylor is wearing thin and seems to get weaker every week.
• 

  juni

  My vote is for Katherine all the way - also my 3 yr. old granddaughter wants her to win. Could it be they share the same name???

  Juni
• 

  minimus

  It's between Catherine and Chris. I personally think Catherine has blossomed each and every week plus she's sweet and beautiful.
• 

  lilybird

  I think out of all of the Idols.. Katherine has improved the most.. She has star quality in that the camera loves her and she can sing anything..I still love Taylor's style .. he is a true performer who is fun to watch.. Elliot and Chris have amazing voices.. They all deserve to win!! Kelly is a sweet pretty girl but not quite an American Idol.....
• 

  willyloman

  Don't worry about Kellie P., she's probably got 125 phone calls from Nashville on her answering machine.
• 

  Star Moore

  Katherine, i think should win.

  But I would like to see Paris..win too.
• 

  lisaBObeesa

  Usual suspect, signing in!

  Yeah, Taylor had a bad night Tuesday.

  But it is ok! 'Change Gonna Come,' 'First Cut Is The Deepest,' 'Levon,' 'Easy,' 'Taking It To The Streets,' 'Living For The City,' 'Trouble,' 'Crazy Little Thing Called Love,' and 'You Send Me' MORE than make up for it!!!

  It will Chris and Taylor, and Taylor will take it home, baby! (God, I hope so!!)

  Whoo!!! LOVIN' ME SOME TAYLOR!!!!
• 

  lisaBObeesa

  Oh yeah, Paris and Elliot are good, too.

  But TAYLOR is number one.