jw I am curious about something.
When I was in the processing of exiting this sect back in 1989, I argued with all 9 of the elders in my congregation (White Rock, Dallas Texas) and they sounded similar to you (and other Witnesses). But I asked them a question they could not answer and I've never seen the Society attempt to address it either.
Say you were Joe Israelite and you were a faithful worshiper of Jehovah. But then one of the bad kings comes along and the temple is turned over to the worship of Baal or Morduk (or some other false god). There are no priests, no Levites, no one teaching the Law correctly. There is no organization and no way to travel safely to the temple in Jerusalem without fear of being killed, or having your wife stolen into prostitution or your children kidnapped and burned alive in sacrifice to a false god.
So the question is: What did that faithful Israelite do? How did he (or she) worship Jehovah without an organization? Realize that one could live out their entire life without ever having the organization Jehovah himself set up to show the way. (It was even worse in the 10 tribe kingdom as they went centuries without the 'true' organization teaching them.) Faithful Joe Israelite would have been on his own. Does he show loyalty to Jehovah's organization or does his follow his Bible trained conscience? Jehovah's organization would be telling him (perhaps even on pain of death or being shunned by his family) to do something he knew to be wrong: follow false gods, believe false teachings and perhaps even put his family in physical danger. And yet his conscience would tell him to reject Baal, reject child sacrifice and stay true to Jehovah. But in so doing, isn't that going against Jehovah's organization?
Realize also that this was an organization Jehovah himself created, painstakingly created laws for, and yet it went apostate. The same thing happened again with the organization Jesus set up. It too went apostate. Two organizations created set up and administered by God himself and his Son, both sending prophets and miracles to keep it going and yet both went apostate. And yet somehow THIS organization, the Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, is incapable of the same fate? This despite the fact that it is only 'spirit directed', with no prophets, no miracles, no Biblical writings to guide it?
My second question to those elders, and to you if you don't mind me asking, is ... why? Why wouldn't this modern religious sect also go astray? What is so special about it that it can avoid the same fate as ancient Israel and Christianity?
Respectfully,
Chris