It started out with this:
I Saw Some JWs Last Night & They Gave Me The Cold Shoulder Like I Was Df'd
Your detail added this:
I saw him, his wife and kids coming from a basketball game, going on the train. He looked right at me, I said, "Hi!" and he put his eyes and head downward as if he couldn't say hello. Hmmmmmm
You allowed us to comment on that, then added details that let us know (eventually) that you were one of three elders that formed the JC that DF'ed this woman whom is obviously attractive. He is still with her, so he must know something about what she did, and what you guys did. It would make no difference if Tom, Dick, or Minimus was the griller, he would know that all 3 were there, discussed her situation, and now probably think less of him being able to keep his woman satisfied or under control or whatever it is.
The woman is there with him when he gives the cold shoulders. He could want her to see how he reacts. He would want to keep a "hottie" like her feeling that her forgiving husband is supportive, especially when he forgave her, but Jehovah did not. Also, the kids are there, so he doesn't want to engage the JC elder in any conversation that might lead to trouble.
Minimus, I believe your entire story- WHY WOULD YOU EVEN BRING IT UP AS A THING THAT MAKES YOU GO "Hmmmmm" ?