Imaginary Friends can help you get over divorce Apparently

by Crumpet 29 Replies latest jw experiences

  • Crumpet
    Crumpet

    Its been suggested to me by someone who clearly is not aware of my atheism that adopting an imaginary friend could help me find my purpose in life after a relationship breakup. It annoys and perplexes me although I realise everyone has a right to their own opinion.

    However my opinion is this:

    My husband hasnt left me - I've never had a husband and I certainly hope I never have that misfortune or get ill enough to suffer such poor judgement as restricting myself to the bed of one person for the rest of my life when I personally am certainly not willing to keep such a promise. We just decided there was nothing new to learn about each other and we both should move onto pastures new. I certainly do not believe in prolonged monogamy for myself whilst I admire those who do (albatrosses and the like) and I am looking forward to new sexual adventures and emotional relationships with new men and women very much.

    I do of course retain a strength of feeling for my ex partner and shall always do so. I think thats much more civilisised that the acrimonious divorce situation that frequently arises from marriage. In marriage it would seen there is a 40% risk that you will begin with a lover and mariage mate and end with an enemy who'd like to kill you and make the rest of your life miserable. I prefer to start with a lover and end with a friend.

    I dont believe imaginary friends are really a good mental strategy to dealing with relationship break ups either. In fact I would caution against such regressive advocacy of emotional dependency on fictional characters. I am a student social scientist and an atheist and believe that wasting time trying to find out what an imaginary being might or might not want is a terrible and fruitless throwing away of your life. I threw 28 years on that through my own stupidity and that of my poor misguided parents and am so happy now that I escaped the mental imprisonment of fantasising about other lives which will never happen instead of living the one I have.

    I don't mean to insult anyone, who does like to indulge in this escape route from real life, but I regard it as effective and purposeful as spending evenings playing computer games - it can be a harmless pasttime as long as it does not become obsession. I certainly wouldn't advocate turning to Elder Scrolls Oblivion or Second Life or Gears of War as entire strategies for overcoming a relationship breakdown anymore than I would Christianity or Islam.

    I am sure anyone who suggests that I follow Jesus does not mean to insult me by suggesting that I owing to a relationship ending am now mentally incapacitated to the extent I would consider reverting to a primitive regressive fantasy world either.

    As a dear friend would now say: BRING IT.

  • cyberdyne systems 101
    cyberdyne systems 101

    I have to agree that i dont think it can really help in such an experience. Having gone through a divorce myself, i think there is no good way to proceed, but a long haul of emotional turmoil that must be gone through in order to face up to it and move forward. I do think doing things to distract you and keeping busy and so on are good things, and perhaps thats what the suggestion was all about, but in the end you still have to go through the pain and difficulty of the experience, although some time out isnt a bad idea.

    Having people to talk to is probably the best thing that helps, to be able to pour out your emotion can be so healing, and its something you want to know is there for you anytime you need it. I've recently began to see how it must have been for my ex, its all to easy to see how it affect yourself, but I also found it healing to acknowledge her pain also and even apologise to her for the pain it caused us both, and my part in any of it.

    Anyway thats my take on what can help get over it

    CS 101

  • Crumpet
    Crumpet

    Cyber - you are so disarming - your post was one of your best ever and look you sucked all the bitterness out of me with your gentle noble words. I think acknowledging hurt you have caused is a very good start at healing!

    ((((cyber-babes))))

  • tijkmo
    tijkmo

    i found that imaginary friends were no help at all

    what i really needed were real friends

    in fact if i had got help from real friends then i probably wouldn't have seperated

    i did co-write a song called imaginary friend with merrymagdelene and that certainly helped a bit

  • Crumpet
    Crumpet

    Merrymags - aint imaginary! She's lovely and very real! and yes i know she is a Muslim and I still think she is fabulous.

    I wonder if there is a word for people like me - you know like homophobic people dont agree with homosexuality, well what do you call people who don't agree with religion but dont have a problem with the people who choose it as a life style?

    (Think I may have opened the path to some insults there!)

  • dedpoet
    dedpoet

    I wonder if there is a word for people like me - you know like homophobic people dont agree with homosexuality, well what do you call people who don't agree with religion but dont have a problem with the people who choose it as a life style?

    I think the word(s) are open-minded Crumpet. Also tolerant of what other people
    choose for themselves, even if their choice is completely at odds with your own,
    and respectful of other peoples views is another way to describe it, in my opinion.

    I'm an atheist as well, but have several friends who choose to follow a religion. I
    have no problem with their choice, they have none with mine, and we don't try
    to persuade each other to adopt our beliefs, or lack of them in my case.

    Trev

  • AK - Jeff
    AK - Jeff

    Crumpet -

    I believe in the imaginary friends that you reject. Still, I think we like each other just fine. So, perhaps those on both sides of the aisle might get along. I also believe in life-long monogamy [33 years and still going]. Just call me Albatross. We may not be 'birds of a feather', but we can still flock together. I take no insult in your words, nor do I send any. If you can accept my silly notions of 'God', I accept your silly notions that He is not.

    Well wishes as you heal.

    Jeff

    <--- HU 16 Flying Albatross [USAF, primarily Vietnam era]

  • nvrgnbk
    nvrgnbk
    I've recently began to see how it must have been for my ex, its all to easy to see how it affect yourself, but I also found it healing to acknowledge her pain also and even apologise to her for the pain it caused us both, and my part in any of it.

    With this approach to life and relationships, you must enjoy a peaceful and fulfilling life cyberdyne systems 101.

    May you continue to grace us with your insightful and positive posting. And no, I'm not kissing your posterior.

    Nvr

    Hang in there Crumpet. All the Imaginary Friends love you a great deal!

    Nvr

  • Crumpet
    Crumpet

    I'm an atheist as well, but have several friends who choose to follow a religion. I
    have no problem with their choice, they have none with mine, and we don't try
    to persuade each other to adopt our beliefs, or lack of them in my case.

    Trev

    Thank you Trev - that is what I object to - to someone telling me i should turn to Jesus. Not that they themselves do.

    Ak-Jeff - you are a lovely lovely man and like I said I do genuinely admire those with the ability to commit - you have to have a lof faith in yourself and a lot of trust in another person - neither of which I do.

    Nvr - I hope you are not being sarky to my homey - cyber!

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe
    I am sure anyone who suggests that I follow Jesus does not mean to insult me by suggesting that I owing to a relationship ending am now mentally incapacitated to the extent I would consider reverting to a primitive regressive fantasy world either.

    Interesting opinion. Openmindedness and tolerance runs both ways...

    Is it truly possible to be a religiophobe with negative exposure to only one religion?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit