Welcome to this site: I know you will enjoy the "company."
There was a young man that was posted a post when I first "came aboard," here, and he had the opposite problem: he was dating a young JW woman.
I told him it was like a Disney movie and he had fallen in love with a "mermaid." I admitted one fact from the illustrations I had seen: the top half is absolutely great, however, it is that "taily" bottom half that presents a problem......
You have fallen in love with a merman: unless you have somending to this story you are.....well.....
screwed. (sorry, I could not come up with another word that is softer....harder...yes.....)
My advice, based on forty years with the JWs: Run. Flee. Abandon Ship. Scoot. Go away.
Gotta go....might comment later...
V
PS: Did I say: "Run like Baptist Hell?....."