iRIVER versus iPOD a Discussion

by Terry 22 Replies latest jw friends

  • Terry
    Terry

    I've owned two different iPODS including the video iPOD.

    I own two different iRIVER products including the new iRIVER CLIX2 (mp3 player, video player, digital recorder and FM radio.)

    To me the iRIVER is the clear winner on all fronts. (Cheaper, too).

    Briefly: iRIVER allows multiple file formats and drag and drop file use. iPOD has the damned iTUNES albatross around your neck and you have all the restrictions about mp4 files.

    With iRIVER you have the addition of equalizer, built in microphone recorder, FM radio, etc.

    Anybody want to weigh in on the benefits/features of one over the other?

    The one thing both players have in common is the crappy earplugs!

    I just bought a pair of Philips SBC HP430 headphones for $14.98 and I'm in heaven! I wouldn't use the "included" earplugs for love or money.

    WATCH THIS DEMO:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-m8aq2TdQ4
  • Terry
    Terry

    Review: Iriver Clix2 portable media player

    A feature packed multimedia player that will fit in your pocket

    Paul Lester, Personal Computer World 04 Jun 2007

    It’s not often that you come across anything particularly surprising in the mp3 market - once you’ve reviewed a certain number of devices from a range of manufacturers you start to notice trends in terms of value, performance and features.

    Iriver isn’t particularly well known for sitting up there with the big boys, despite producing some appealing offerings in the past, but in the Clix2 it has truly surpassed itself by producing one of the best players we’ve seen in recent times.

    The front of this slimline device is almost totally taken up by the 2.2in display, which may cause those who haven’t seen the original Clix, released earlier this year, to wonder how you find your way around. As a quick refresher, the Clix2 uses a four-way depressible display for navigation, meaning you simply press down on the corresponding edge of the device to move around the menus.

    Despite being a little sceptical at first, we found this method to be extremely effective. You will find additional volume, power and hotkey buttons subtly integrated into the edges, along with the obvious inclusion of a hold button to stop it browsing around at random when in your pocket.

    Starting the device up reveals the first of many great things we have to say about the Clix2, namely the excellent active matrix OLED display. The bright, vibrant and superbly sharp screen does a great job of either showing off your photos via the built-in browser or video files encoded using the Iriver Plus 3 software provided. A 2.2in display is about the minimum size required to genuinely enjoy video content on a portable player, although you'll find it hard to settle into a feature film.

    In addition to photo and video support, you’ll find a built in recordable FM radio and, of course, an mp3 player, which brings us to the next big selling point. Audio quality is superb, which in no small part down to the wide range of enhancements and effects you can apply. We'd recommend picking up some decent in-ear bud ‘phones to use with the Clix2 as the ones supplied are adequate, but don’t come close to reaching its potential.

    On top of all this you’ll find a wide range of additional features including an alarm clock, voice recorder, text viewer and a range of flash games that utilise the unique controls of the Clix2 to good effect. It’s also extremely customisable, as well as changing the background to any of the preloaded photos or one from an uploaded collection, you can change the theme, including the menu structure, operation and choice of fonts, to produce some extremely stylish and unique effects.

    It’s very difficult to think of many features the Clix2 lacks. We did notice that video encoding does take a surprisingly long time via the supplied software, and while you can transfer music and photos via drag and drop you’re better off using Iriver Plus 3 to standardise your collection. It’s also a little short on playlist control, and you won’t find the traditional artist/album/genre selection for tunes, but this shouldn’t cause too many problems.

    Despite these minor drawbacks, we were extremely impressed with the Clix2. A very reasonable price tag of just £139 and 4GB capacity means it’s slightly more expensive than Apple's equivalent Nano (which has incidentally been through a number of price drops since its initial release) but the features and performance of the Clix2 means its leagues ahead of Apple’s baby.

  • What-A-Coincidence
    What-A-Coincidence

    iRiver hands down.

  • theinfamousone
    theinfamousone

    i have had nothing but ipods and am honestly sick of itunes... i think my next purchase will be an iriver... aww well, 300 bux down the drain!

    the infamous one

  • monophonic
    monophonic

    i went with iriver b/c i hate the being stuck using itunes to organize my mp3s.

    with limited use, my iriver h320 battery would die after about seven minutes.

    they wouldn't exchange it b/c i had it just over a year, even though i probably used it once every two weeks.

    i loved that i could make my own file directory options, but the battery thing and lack of tech support drove me to go with Creative, which was originally Dell, and Dell has never steered me wrong on tech support.

    the creative i have is a 30gb w/ video and $100 less than the ipod 30gb.

    i like that there isn't an itunes type interface, but it does try to organize your files on its own, i need to figure out how to make my own directory structure.

    ipod has excellent support, my wife replaced hers twice w/ the one year warranty....she dropped it left and right and both times they replaced the unit w/o issues.

  • drew sagan
    drew sagan

    I've actually installed some of the ipod linux systems on my older ipod with a degree of success. It will play a larger variety of files and has some neat features. Of course, this isn't supported by apple.

    The iriver is only 4gb??? That's enough to keep me away.

  • Terry
    Terry

    I gave my iPOD video to my daughter.

    ITunes got to me and I couldn't take it anymore.

    People sell their no-longer-beloved-audio trinkets easily on Ebay. Make a few bucks off your gear.

    Give it a go.

  • Terry
    Terry
    i went with iriver b/c i hate the being stuck using itunes to organize my mp3s.

    with limited use, my iriver h320 battery would die after about seven minutes.

    they wouldn't exchange it b/c i had it just over a year, even though i probably used it once every two weeks.

    I had an issue a couple of years ago with an iRIVER mp3 player, but, they couldn't have been nicer. Replaced it with a brand new one.

    I think it may come down to two things: Try being very personable with the person on the phone. Ask their advice. Request (never demand) assistance. Thank them repeatedly for "being so nice and helpful" (Their boss is often monitoring the call!).

    Often, customer service devolves to one on one human contact. Customer support can be a thankless endless bitch session.

    I always try to be very warm and vulnerable to tech support. So far, so good.

  • Terry
    Terry
    The iriver is only 4gb??? That's enough to keep me away.

    I keep a thumbdrive for portable file transport and a stand-alone hardrive (160gb) for backup and storage.

    I only use my portable players for immediate use; never long-term storage.

    4GB is a lot, actually. More than I could possibly listen to in a 48 hour orgy of listening session.

    But, some folks are packrats and want it all with them at all times.

    Different tune; different drummer you might say :)

  • Descender
    Descender

    I'd like to have the ability to check out all of the portable media and music players, but I don't have the extra funds. But I do know that for my own personal preference I will usually only use one when I'm walking or riding the trails, mowing the lawn, or working out, so the video option isn't needed. Also, I want the smallest player available.

    Luckily, my wife and my dogs got me an ipod shuffle for doggy father's day. It's barely bigger than the end of my thumb and it clips on to my shirt or shorts. And my wife has an ipod and several thousand songs that she's downloaded to itunes over the years that I can choose from. So I used my shuffle for the first time last night while working out and it was great. At my gym, they keep XM radio tuned to 80's hairbands all the time. It gets old really quick. I don't like the earplugs though, they fell out twice last night and felt like they were going to fall out the rest of the time.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit