Did The Watchtower Society Give You Your Personality?

by The wanderer 25 Replies latest jw friends

  • AllAlongTheWatchtower
    AllAlongTheWatchtower

    I would like to be able to resoundingly say 'no', but there are little niggling doubts in the back of my mind, at times, that my high control group (WCG, not JW) upbringing had such far-reaching effects that everything I do is simply a reaction to it, no matter how much I might wish/think/protest otherwise. I will occassionally analyze my life and actions, in an attempt to dispute this, and I'm not always happy with the conclusions. I am reminded of the MacBeth quote "...methinks the lady doth protest too much".

    Smoking: This is at least one thing that I know for a fact I started doing in direct defiance of WCG teachings and general rebellion against them, and my parents. Still stuck with this one.

    Alcohol/drugs: Something else I know for a fact that I started doing simply to defy WCG and parents, and out of curiousity as well, I suppose. Unlike with smoking, this one ran it's course, fun for a while, but not who I am today. The partying lifestyle is not for me.

    Atheism: Were it not for becoming angry enough to investigate religion on my own, I may have never become atheist. 'Normal' Christianity is fairly mild, and I may have accepted it had I been raised that way. However, I consider it a winding road full of thought and effort that I followed to atheism, and I resent when someone implies that it was a direct path...a kneejerk reaction to cult or high control group participation. But is my self-perception valid, or wishful thinking?

    Military: This one I'm not sure about...at the time I joined, I would have said I was doing it for college money, life experience, and because as a kid just turning too old to stay in the state juvenile system, I had no idea what else to do with my life, and had to do SOMETHING which would provide me with a place to live. In retrospect, I often wonder was this just yet another taboo to break, subconsciously.

    My marriage: This is the one that can really keep me up at night. In the WCG, interracial relationships were forbidden, but I am now married to a black woman. I love her dearly, and it pains me to the quick to even think that our relationship might be based on some mental checklist of 'what taboo have I not broken yet?', but I do wonder just that, sometimes, a sort of self-torture, I guess you could say. I would LIKE to think that I am simply a more enlightened individual than some, with the ability to see beyond skin color to the person within...that I possess the traits of acceptance, reason, logic, fairness...etc etc. But what if it's all just self-delusion...what if, what if, what if...this is the mantra that can spiral down and down, unendingly.

  • BluesBrother
    BluesBrother

    "Putting on the new personality" , eh?

    Dictionaries have differing definitions for the word

    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source

    per·son·al·i·ty alt / ?p?ralts?'nælalt?altti / Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation [ pur-suh-nal-i-tee ] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation –noun, plural -ties.

    1.the visible aspect of one's character as it impresses others: He has a pleasing personality.
    2.a person as an embodiment of a collection of qualities: He is a curious personality.
    3.Psychology .
    a.the sum total of the physical, mental, emotional, and social characteristics of an individual.
    b.the organized pattern of behavioral characteristics of the individual.
    4.the quality of being a person; existence as a self-conscious human being; personal identity.
    5.

    the essential character of a person"

    .

    Number one is definately true . The strict rules and moral training to mold Witnesses to be alike and united certainly changes the visible aspect of a person. Does it change number five "The essential character of a person? I think not. Just put a dub in a particularly stressful unexpected circumstance - Like any human being, the essential character will show up.

  • RollerDave
    RollerDave

    ABSOLUTELY NOT.

    But it wasn't for lack of trying.

    I was a relatively normal baby, but multiple trips to the ER for things like concussion and poisoning show something was wrong. I was basically destroyed as a person before age five. Ruined and killed inside.

    Then things changed and some of me grew back, but not well or nicely.

    So, as a child and teen, they WANTED to wreck me inside with their theocratic bullshit, but I didn't fit in among the 'world' OR the witlesses.

    A lot of my personality came from my mother, who had some rather unique ideas. Things like, "it's a sin to 'love' a pet"

    If they had been able to impose their mold on my personality, they would not have turned me out.

    And since then, I have had to rip it all out and start fresh.

    Some things I have kept, but others have graced the dustbin.

    But, in short; they only failed to ruin me because somebody else killed me first.

    Roller

  • Open mind
    Open mind

    Yep. To whatever extent "nurture" (as opposed to "nature") plays in shaping the personality, the dubs were HUGE in shaping me.

    Out of all the 9 "fruitages of the Spirit" that dubs are supposed to try cultivating, only two are effectively beaten into a "company man's" psyche: Long-suffering & Self-Control.

    Put another way: The ability to put up with loads of crap from those in authority and make it look like you like it.

    All the rest of the "fruitages" are fairly optional and you can survive in dubland without them. But if you can't keep your yap shut when you feel like screaming, you won't even get the "privilege" of toting a microphone.

    In the working world this has actually helped me. Being able to bite my tongue at crucial times has helped me keep jobs and/or get promotions.

    Am I grateful for this? No. I definitely would have preferred growing up out from under the Borg yoke even if it cost me a job or two.

    Open Mind

  • LoverOfTruth
    LoverOfTruth

    I believe our basic personality is with us when we are born. Our life experiences, including involvement with Jehovah's Witnesses contribute to our behaviors and growth. While I'm happy to have been out over 20 years now, I cherish those who were my dear friends.... and I miss them.

  • keyser soze
    keyser soze

    I was never truly comfortable being defined in that way. Even though I believed at the time that it was the truth, there were many times when I felt like I was never truly one of them. Maybe that was my subconscious trying to tell me something and I ignored it. I do know that I've grown a lot as a person just in the less than two years that I've been out.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit