Are the accountants merely following a formula?

by OnTheWayOut 11 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut

    Bethel was full of people, departments, assignments. A growing corporation often
    has waste. When you don't provide salaries, it's even easier to have too many people.
    Printing on multimillion dollar presses only takes a handful of people. Cut-and-paste
    writing from old information and recycling artwork only takes a couple of people with
    good "searching" skills. I don't believe that Brooklyn Bethel was losing money when
    they sent people home, but the accountants said that even paying for their food and
    lodging was impractical anymore.

    Hardcover stock is gone for years, now. Hardcover Bibles are finally running out and
    the paperbacks are winding up in the bookbags. Awake is down by half, WT is reducing,
    and everyone speculates more reductions; perhaps the OKM will be put into the mag.
    Yearly distribution work has included offering flyers to come to the Memorial, the DC, and
    Kingdom News #37 (38?). I doubt that the profits were gone on the expensive materials,
    but profits were in a downward spiral. The accountants probably want to maintain a
    profit percentage, and dipped below it.

    Assembly Halls are being built, others are being remodeled. Even though growth is
    virtually nonexistent in areas like the U.S., they continue this work. Property acquisition
    is a standard wealth-building strategy. Even remodeling with local contributions and
    free labor allows you to spend the money any way you want to, or perhaps even to
    keep some of the money for the corporation if more than enough is donated.

    Bookstudy meetings are covering old information. A new book every year would be
    covered in 6 months, so an old book needs to be mixed in with it. The obvious solution
    would be to produce 2 new books (been done often in the past). That doubles the cost
    of product at the conventions. Keeping the product cost down doesn't significantly change
    the donations, so profits are much higher if 1 book or brochure is released.

    Thanks for reading all that. My question is simple. Is the supposedly "spiritual" organization
    merely being run by accountants? Not that the GB isn't making the decisions, but aren't
    the accountants telling them what needs to be done? Isn't every area of potential income
    scrutinized, and when the profit level drops below XX %, there is a new change?
    Doesn't this mean that the exciting changes they are seeing will just continue more and more?
    When your offerings and products get cheaper, you can't suddenly expect a big turnaround.

  • MadTiger
    MadTiger

    As an MBA and a business consultant/analyst (and former Witnoid!), this interests me.

    My opinion is that they keep watch on things like utility bills, food bills, insurance bills, etc., and compare it to rank-and-file headcount. They obviously keep count of the profit margins on the literature publishing business and event management (assembly/convention) business.

    They manage the number of volunteer slave-soldiers at the headquarters accordingly.

  • MadTiger
    MadTiger

    I forgot to mention the real estate development business!

  • MadTiger
    MadTiger

    I guess my point is this: they count the toilet paper squares just like some of our elders and ministerial servants did!!!

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut
    they count the toilet paper squares just like some of our elders and ministerial servants did!!!

    They already tell you how much towel to use at Assemblies.
    Next, they will tell families to bring their own tissue and towels.

    Stop laughing, it will happen.

  • NewYork44M
    NewYork44M

    The wt is a business. The wt is run like a business. The goal of a business is to maximize profits. Thus, nothing is "off limits" when it comes time to cut expenses.

    The formula that you describe is exactly what a business must follow to stay in business. Do you expect any different from the business identified as the wtbts??

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut
    Do you expect any different from the business identified as the wtbts??

    Do I expect any different- no. A couple of years ago, I did.

    They are supposed to be spreading the lifesaving Good News worldwide.
    Jesus gave them a commission in 1919 (or possibly sooner, depending
    on the exact point they are trying to make).

    If they have a commission from Jesus, the king in heaven (or Michael the
    leader of the angelic armies) and Jehovah backs their commission, expenses
    should not be the issue. GOD will make sure they don't get bogged down
    because of money. A truckload of fresh food breaks down at the JW site
    or border guards mysteriously don't inspect the smuggled literature. If so,
    then keep producing quality literature, stop dismissing Bethelites. OR if
    you run it like a business, then admit it's a business.

    Even faithful dubs can see through the hollow excuses on cutbacks. That's
    a good thing in my mind, but it doesn't fit with my former JW thinking.
    "GOD WILL PROVIDE. Well, in case He doesn't, we'll take some precautions."

  • NewYork44M
    NewYork44M

    A general truth about life is EVERYTHING (and I mean EVERYTHING) is about money. That is neither a good thing nor a bad thing - it just is.

    If some one tells you something is not about money, they are lying and you shoud run like hell.

    the wt pretends they are not about money. But guess what, they are lying to you and me and possibly to themselves.

  • cultswatter
    cultswatter
    Is the supposedly "spiritual" organization merely being run by accountants?

    Yes!!. It is the math of economics that determine that. The accountants must determine which scheme maximizes profit and minimizes losses. Basic high school algebra really.

    The way the Borg is run has absoluetly nothing to do with the holy spirit. The holy spirit wants hardcover bibles with gold trim but the math says that this will be a money loser.

  • minimus
    minimus

    Watchtower has ALWAYS been a business. Accountants and lawyers run it all.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit