Wow, thanks to everyone for there info. This is gonna take a while to read.
thanks
smoky
what is WT Circular Reasoning/logic?
by Smoky 14 Replies latest jw experiences
-
-
changeling
You tell your kid to do something, he asks why, you say "because I said so".
-
OnTheWayOut
Without actually quoting the proof (you can do that on your own) I will give you
an example of circular reasoning-Jesus chose the WT organization as his Faithful and Discreet Slave in 1919.
The fact that they are the only ones dispensing accurate spiritual food is
proof that they were chosen.BUT THEIR MESSAGE HAS CHANGED OVER THE YEARS.
Well, Jehovah reveals the truth to them progressively. As we are ready to
handle more spiritual truth, more is revealed. The light gets brighter as more
is revealed.SO WHAT WERE THEY DOING IN 1919 THAT WAS "RIGHT" MORE SO THAN
THE REST OF CHRISTENDOM?They were proclaiming that Jesus was enthroned as King in 1914 and that
soon would bring about the establishment of God's Kingdom on Earth.THEY WEREN'T PROCLAIMING THAT IN 1919. IT WAS ONLY LATER THAT
THEY SAID THIS. BACK THEN, THEY SAID JESUS WAS INVISIBLY PRESENT
SINCE 1874.Yeah, the light got brighter and the truth was refined.
BUT THEN, THEY WERE NOT PROCLAIMING WHAT YOUR MAGAZINES
SAY THEY WERE PROCLAIMING.Yes, they were. The truth was just 'refined.' They must have been proclaiming
the truth because, after all, Jesus chose them. -
RollerDave
The WTS is God's channel.
Why? It says so in the bible.
Where? Matt 24, the F&DS parable is really a prophecy.
How do we know that? The WTS interpreted it that way.
Why can we believe them? They are God's channel
RD
-
DannyHaszard
http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/12/109539/1.ashx damn good thread
Articulator Manipulator The four most common breakdowns in logical thinking: 1.hasty generalizations 2illogical predictions 3 argument against the person 4 false cause (I suggest we know just the top 4 for now)
