For Blondie- Comments on 8/12 Study Article: Return Evil for Evil to No One

by OnTheWayOut 18 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut

    I cannot do this again, but I thought I would try it once.
    I will try to post this scan for this one time during Blondie's break.
    I am not as computer-skilled as some, so I hope it works.
    Here's the study article for this week's WT lesson around the
    world at the Kingdom Halls (along with a few comments in boxes)-

    "RETURN EVIL FOR EVIL TO NO ONE"
    Theme text-
    "Return evil for evil to no one.Provide fine things in the
    sight of all men. "-ROMANS 12:17.
    Sounds simple enough, but this box in the center (see below)

    will already remind us that JW's do this differently with

    fellow believers than they do with unbelievers
    Box in center of page states:
    Romans chapter 12 describes a Christian's relationship with
    . Jehovah
    . fellow believers
    . unbelievers
    1 WHEN a child is shoved by a sibling, usually the child's first reaction 
    is to shove back. Sadly, such tit-for-tat behav­ior is not limited to
    children. Many adults act similarly. When offended by someone, they want
    to get even. Granted, most adults will not give a literal shove, but many
    will push back in subtle ways. Perhaps they spread harmful gossip about
    the offender or find ways to pre­vent him from succeeding. Whatever method
    is used, the intent is the same-to repay in kind, to retaliate.
    They said "tit." What a brave forward-moving group. Snickers for all the

    adolescents and many adults.
    I guess repaying the WTS in kind for all the abuse heaped upon members

    would be considered childish by paragraph 1's tone.
    1. What type of behavior is not uncommon?
    2 Although the urge to get even is deep-seated, true Christians resist 
    giving in to it. Instead, they strive to follow the apostle Paul's
    admonition: "Return evil for evil to no one." (Romans 12:17) What will
    moti­vate us to live according to that high stan­dard? Whom in particular
    should we not re­pay with evil? What benefits will be reaped if we refrain
    from getting even? To answer those questions, let us study the context of
    Paul's words and see how Romans chap­ter 12 shows that refraining from
    retaliation is the right, the loving, and the modest course to follow.
    We will consider these three aspects, one at a time.
    "...let us study the context of Paul's words and see how..."

    Make sure you don't use outside study material. They are actually saying

    "Let us tell you what Paul meant and you just agree."
    2. (a) Why do true Christians resist the urge to re­taliate? 
    (b) What questions and which Bible chapter will we consider?
    I love the questions like (b) above. They say "See, we are doing deep

    research and answering Bible questions." YEAH, the questions WTS tells

    you to be asking, along with their answers.
    "Consequently I Entreat You"
    3 Beginning in chapter 12, Paul considers four related subjects that 
    affect a Chris­tian's life. He describes our relationship with Jehovah,
    with fellow believers, with non­believers, and with governmental
    author­ities. Paul indicates that there is a fun­damental reason to
    resist wrong inclinations, includ­ing the urge to retaliate, when he
    states: "Conse­quently I entreat you by the compassions of God,
    broth­ers." (Romans 12:1) Note the word" consequently' which means
    "in view of the foregoing." Paul in ef­fect says, 'In view of what I
    just explained to you, I entreat you to do what I will tell you next.'
    What had Paul ex­plained to those Christians in Rome?
    "Paul considers four related subjects that affect a Chris­tian's life. 
    He describes our relationship with Jehovah, with fellow believers, with
    non­believers, and with governmental author­ities."



    Why did they sneak in #4 without putting it in the box in the middle of
    the page (quoted at the beginning of the article)? Could it be that they
    didn't want newbies to notice that JW's are instructed to have a particular

    relationship with governmental authorities? Hmmmm....
    "Paul in ef­fect says, 'In view of what I just explained to you, I entreat
    you to do what I will tell you next.' "



    WTS must love that quote. Give Paul such authority because the GB is now standing in
    the place of Paul- God's representative churning out God's instructions.
    4 In the first 11 chapters of his letter, Paul discussed the wonderful 
    opportunity open to both Jews and Gentiles to become rul­ers with Christ
    in God's Kingdom, a hope that natural Israel failed to accept.
    (Romans 11:13-36) That precious privilege became possible only "by the
    compassions of God." How should Christians respond to this great
    undeserved kindness on God's part? Their hearts should be filled with
    such deeply felt gratitude that they would be moved to do what Paul
    states next: "Present your bodies a sacrifice living, holy, acceptable
    to God, a sa­cred service with your power of reason." (Romans 12:1) How,
    though, could those Christians actually present themselves "a sacrifice"
    to God?
    "How should Christians respond to this great undeserved kindness on God's part?"

    Why couldn't WTS have left that question unanswered? Christians in the room
    should be able to determine how they should respond. BUT NO- they TELL you
    what your reply to their question should be- same as always.
    3, 4. (a) Beginning with Romans chapter 12, what does Paul discuss, 
    and what is the significance of his use of the word "consequently"?
    (b) What effect should God's compassion have had on the Chris­tians in Rome?
    Just in case you didn't get the point from the paragraph, (b) reiterates
    the WTS directions. "Respond as we tell you, be effected the way we tell you to."
    5 Paul goes on to explain: "Quit being fashioned after this system of 
    things, but qe transformed by making your mind over, that you may prove
    to yourselves the good and acceptable and perfect will of God."
    (Ro­mans 12:2) Instead of allowing the spirit of the world to shape their
    thinking, they needed to make their minds over to Christ's way of thinking.
    (1 Corinthians 2:16; Philip­pians 2:5) That principle should influence the
    day-to-day behavior of all genuine Chris­tians, including us today.
    Puh-lease. "...Christ's way of thinking. (1 Corinthians 2:16; Philip­pians 2:5)
    That principle should influence the day-to-day behavior of all genuine Chris­tians,
    including us today."

    But WTS will tell you how to behave so that you don't have to decide what influence
    Christ should have on you today.
    5. (a) How can a person offer himself "a sacri­fice" to God? 
    (b) What principle should influence a Christian's behavior?
    (b) Are you supposed to think "principle" or "principal" ? Because the first
    answer is "the leaders." Parrot your answer from the paragraph, but you should
    remember to let the leaders influence your behaviour.
    6 How does Paul's reasoning at Romans 12:1, 2 help us? Like those 
    spirit-anointed Christians in Rome, we are deeply grateful for the
    continuing and manifold expres­sions of compassion that God has given us and
    continues to give us every day of our life. Consequently, a heart filled
    with gratitude moves us to serve God with all our strength, means, and
    abilities. That heartfelt desire also moves us to do-our utmost to think,
    not like the world, but like Christ. And having the mind of Christ affects
    how we treat oth­ers-both fellow believers and nonbelievers. (Galatians 5:25)
    A case in point: If we think like Christ,- we are compelled to resist the
    urge to retaliate.-l Peter 2:21-23.
    Serious cult language in paragraph 6, I must comment.
    In Para. 3, was this thought:
    Note the word" consequently' which means "in view of the foregoing."
    Paul in ef­fect says, 'In view of what I just explained to you, I
    entreat you to do what I will tell you next.'

    Now they say in para. 6:
    Consequently, a heart filled with gratitude moves us to serve God
    with all our strength, means, and abilities.
    So, when we read "consequently" in any WT literature, we are now to
    think, "In view of what I just explained to you, I entreat you to do
    what I will tell you next."
     
    6. Based on Paul's reasoning found at Romans 12: I, 2, what moves us to avoid retaliating?
    "Let Your Love Be Without Hypocrisy"
    7 We refrain from returning evil for evil not only because it is the right 
    course but also because it is the loving course. Note how the apostle Paul
    next considers the mo­tive of love. In the book of Romans, Paul uses the word
    "love" (a.ga'pe in Greek) sev­eral times when referring to God's love and that
    of Christ. (Romans 5:5, 8; 8:35, 39) However, in chapter 12, Paul uses a.ga'pe
    in a different way- in speaking about love shown to fellow humans. After noting
    that spiritual gifts vary and are present among some believers, Paul mentions
    a quality that should be cultivated by all Christians. He states: "Let your
    love be without hypocri­sy." (Romans 12:4-9) Showing love to others is a basic
    mark of true Christians. (Mark 12:28-31) Paul exhorts us to make sure that the
    love we show as Christians is sincere.
    7. What type of love is consid­ered in Romans chapter 12?
    8 Further, Paul notes how love with­out hypocrisy is shown, stating: "Ab­hor what 
    is wicked, cling to what is good." (Romans 12:9) "Ab­hor" and" cling" are strong
    words. "Abhor" can be trans­lated "hate exceedingly." We must hate not merely the
    consequences of evil but also the evil itself. (Psalm 97:10) The word "cling" is
    a transla­tion of a Greek verb that literally means "to glue." A Christian who has
    genuine love is so firmly glued, or attached, to the quality of goodness that it
    becomes an inseparable part of his personality.
    Last sentence above means: A JW must show his genuine love by clinging to anything
    the WT says, don't let intelligent (worldly) thinking penetrate your personality.
    8. How can we show unhypo­critical love?
    9 One particular manifestation of love is mentioned by Paul again and again. He 
    states: "Keep on blessing those who perse­cute; be blessing and do not be cursing."
    "Return evil for evil to no one." "Do not avenge yourselves, beloved." "Do not let
    yourself be conquered by the evil, but keep conquering the evil with the good."
    (Ro­mans 12:14, 17-19, 21) Paul's words leave no doubt about how we should treat
    non­believers, even those who oppose us.
    Paul's words leave no doubt, but let us tell you what they mean as we go on.
    9. What admonition does Paul give again and again?
    "Keep  On  Blessing Those Who Persecute"
    10 How do we carry out Paul's exhorta­tion: "Keep on blessing those who perse­cute"? 
    (Romans 12:14) Jesus told his follow­ers: "Continue to love your enemies and to pray
    for those persecuting you." (Matthew 5:44; Luke 6:27, 28) Hence, one way in which we
    bless persecutors is by praying for them, petitioning God that if any are oppos­ing
    us because of ignorance, Jehovah may open their eyes to the truth. (2 Corinthians 4:4)
    Granted, it may seem strange to ask God to bless a persecutor. However, the more our
    mind-set resembles Christ's way of think­ing, the more we will be able to extend love
    to our enemies. (Luke 23:34) What can be the result of showing such love?
    10. In what way can we bless our persecutors?
    11 Stephen was one who prayed for his per­secutors, and his prayer was not in vain. 
    Not long after Pentecost 33 C.E., Stephen was ar­rested by opposers of the Christian
    con­gregation, dragged outside Jerusalem, and stoned. Before he died, he cried out:
    "Jeho­vah, do not charge this sin against them." (Acts 7:58-8:1) One of the men for
    whom Stephen prayed that day was Saul, who wit­nessed and approved of Stephen's murder.
    Later, the resurrected Jesus appeared to Saul. That former persecutor became a follower
    of Christ and went on to become the apostle Paul, the writer of the letter to the Ro­mans.
    (Acts 26: 12-18) In line with Stephen's prayer, Jehovah evidently forgave Paul for the
    sin of being a persecutor. (1 Timo­thy 1:12-16) No wonder that Paul exhorted Christians:
    "Keep on blessing those who persecute"! He knew from experience that some persecutors may
    eventually become servants of God. In our day, some persecu­tors have likewise become
    believers because of the peaceable conduct of Jehovah's ser­vants.
    Bless those that oppose the cult and keep trying to convert them.
    11. (a) What can we learn from the example of Ste­phen? 
    (b) As illustrated by Paul's life, what change may occur in some persecutors?
    "Be Peaceable With All Men"
    12 Paul's next admonition on how to treat believers and unbelievers is: "Return 
    evil for evil to no one." That statement is a logical consequence of what he said
    earlier, name­ly: "Abhor what is wicked." After all, how could a person say that he
    truly abhors what is wicked, or evil, if he were to use evil as a means to repay
    others? Doing so would be the opposite of having love "without hypocrisy." Then Paul
    says: "Provide fine things in the sight of all men." (Romans 12: 9,17) How do we apply
    those words?
    12. How are the words of admonition found at Ro­mans 12:9, 17 related?
    13 Earlier, in his letter to the Corinthians, Paul wrote about the persecution that the 
    apostles faced. He said: "We have become a theatrical spectacle to the world, and to
    an­gels, and to men. . . . When being reviled, we bless; when being persecuted, we bear up;
    when being defamed, we entreat." (1 Corin­thians 4:9-13) Similarly, true Christians to­day
    are being watched by the people of this world. When those around us observe the fine
    things we do even while we are being treated unjustly, they may be inclined to look more
    favorably upon our Christian message.-l Peter 2:12.
    I gotta wonder, do the rank&file really get concerned that the worldly ones are watching
    or that the elders are watching?
    13. In what way do we conduct ourselves "in the sight of all men"?
    14 How far, though, should we  go  in order  to  promote peace? We should  go  as far as 
    possi­ble. Paul tells his Chris­tian brothers: "If possi­ble, as far as it depends upon you, be peaceable with all men." (Romans 12: 18) "If possible" and "as far as it depends upon
    you" are qualifying ex­ pressions indicating that making peace with others may not always be
    possi­ble. For instance, we will not disobey a command of God just to keep peace with man.
    (Matthew 10:34-36; Hebrews 12:14) Still, we do everything we reasonably can-with­out
    compromising righ­teous principles-to make peace "with all men."
    "...we will not disobey a command of God just to keep peace with man."
    We will obey the WTS before we make peace with family members that try to warn us.
    14. How far should we go in order to make peace? 
    "Do  Not  Avenge Yourselves"
    15 Paul gives another compelling reason why we should not retaliate; it is the modest 
    course to -follow. He states: "Do not avenge yourselves, beloved, but yield place to the
    wrath; for it is written: 'Vengeance is mine; I will repay, says]ehovah.'" (Romans 12:19)
    A Christian who tries to take revenge is pre­sumptuous. He claims for himself a role that
    belongs to God. (Matthew 7:1) Moreover, by taking matters into his own hands, he shows a
    lack of faith in Jehovah's assurance: "I will repay." In contrast, true Christians trust
    that Jehovah will "cause justice to be done for his chosen ones." (Luke 18:7, 8;
    2 Thessalonians 1:6-8) They modestly leave the avenging of wrong in God's hands.
    -Jer­emiah 30:23,24; Romans 1:18.
    "A Christian who tries to take revenge is pre­sumptuous."
    The entire para. above sounds like training to convince JW's not to sue the WTS.
    15. What reason to forgo retaliation is found at Ro­mans 12:19?
    16 Taking vengeance on an enemy would likely harden his spirit, but treating him with 
    kindness may soften his heart. Why? Note Paul's words to the Christians in Rome. He says:
    "If your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink; for by
    doing this you will heap fiery coals upon his head." (Romans 12:20; Proverbs 25:21,22)
    What does this mean?
    17 To "heap fiery coals upon his head" is a figure of speech drawn from the method of 
    smelting metals in Bible times. Ore was put into a furnace, and a layer of coals was put
    not only underneath the ore but also on top of it. Fiery coals heaped on top increased the
    heat so that the hard metal melted and sepa­rated from the impurities in the ore. Similar­ly,
    by doing kind deeds to an opposer, we may "melt" his hardness and bring out his better
    qualities. (2 Kings 6: 14-23) In fact, nu­merous members of the Christian congre­gation were
    first attracted to true worship by the kind deeds that Jehovah's servants per­formed in their
    behalf.
    "...doing kind deeds to an opposer..."
    Do they really mean that? Are JW's doing kind deeds to opposers?
    They disfellowship any former believers. This is just loaded language to
    keep recruiting anyone you know who doesn't take to the cult.
    16, 17. (a) What does it mean to "heap fiery coals" upon someone's head? 
    (b) Have you personally ob­served how kindness softened the heart of an un­believer?
    If so, give an example.
    Why We Do Not Retaliate
    18 In this brief consideration of Romans chapter 12, we have seen several important 
    reasons why we "return evil for evil to no one." First, holding back from retaliating is the
    right course to follow. In view of God's compassion shown toward us, it is right and
    reasonable that we offer ourselves to Jehovah and willingly obey his com­mandments-including
    the command to love our enemies. Second, refusing to return evil for evil is the loving
    course to fol­low. By forgoing retaliation and promot­ing peace, we lovingly hope to help even
    some fierce opposers to become worship­pers of Jehovah. Third, refrainin'g from re­paying with
    evil is the modest course to follow. Avenging ourselves would be pre­sumptuous, for Jehovah
    states: "Vengeance is mine." God's Word also warns: "Has presumptuousness come? Then dishonor
    will come; but wisdom is with the modest ones." (Proverbs 11:2) Wisely leaving the avenging of
    wrong in God's hands shows modesty on our part.
    "...we lovingly hope to help even some fierce opposers to become worship­pers of Jehovah."
    Yes, as I suspected, loaded language to keep recruiting worldly opposers.
    18. Why is it right, loving, and modest not to retal­iate?
    19 Paul sums up his discussion of how we should treat others. He exhorts Christians: "Do not 
    let yourself be conquered by the evil, but keep conquering the. evil with the good."
    (Romans 12:21) What evil forces are we facing today? How can we conquer them? The answers to
    these and related questions will be considered in the follow­ing article.
    "What evil forces are we facing today?"
    We never discussed governmental authorities. Could that be the evil forces.
    Tune in to next week's lesson to find out.
    19. What will we consider in the following article?
    Review Box
    Can You Explain?
    In Romans chapter 12, what admoni­tion is found again and again?
    What will motivate us not to retaliate?
    What benefits will be reaped by us and others if we do not "return evil for evil"?
  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut

    Scanning is hard work. Forgive me for BTTT.

  • Awakened07
    Awakened07

    I haven't read it all (I will), but I just thought I'd commend you for doing the work, in the absence of Blondie's work.

  • Robert222
    Robert222

    Thank you for the WA review.

    I also think this article, in part, is about "dont sue the WA society" or the local congregation for any wrongdoing. Just let it go, continue to suffer in silence while the perpetrators are protected.

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    Great job, OTWO! I am reminded of Moses' helpers who held up his hands when he got tired. As for this article, I tend to agree. Perhaps the society fears that news of past settlements will inspire more Witnesses and former Witnesses to step forward to make claims.

  • nvrgnbk
    nvrgnbk

    Nice effort, OTWO.

    Looks like alot of work.

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut

    Looks like alot of work.

    Well, I didn't type it- just scanned it. Sad, though. I have avoided the WT magazine for awhile.
    They are still in the house, but have managed to stay out of my hand for a long time, and here
    I had to pick one up. Blondie reads this drivel every week for us, I usually just look over her
    notes and read some of what grabs my attention from her thoughts.

  • WTWizard
    WTWizard

    Excellent effort. Though this is not like Blondie's commentaries, it is an excellent first effort on doing with no experience what she has been doing since at least 2004 and probably even longer. With that kind of experience, and when you improve with computer skills, I am sure it will get even better.

    Not to mention that she puts in a lot of work actually preparing for it. She spends as much time studying the material as the average Witless does to prepare for the meeting (or is supposed to), only to critically analyze it. And then it takes more time to type it up, along with the comments and switching back and forth from bold and red to normal. Great effort.

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut
    Not to mention that she puts in a lot of work actually preparing for it.

    Yes, but with her leaner format coming up, it is up to YOU to provide more commentary.

  • OnTheWayOut
    OnTheWayOut
    Para. 13- ...When those around us observe the fine things we do even while we are being treated
    unjustly, they may be inclined to look more favorably upon our Christian message.

    Can JW's follow this counsel as they determine that they are being treated unfairly by the
    media? Does the GB do so?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit