sweetstuff recommended:
Take her out, do something she would never do with her "brothers and sisters". Maybe dancing at a nice club if she's open to that. I would very carefully afterward, tell her how much you loved seeing her happy and having fun, and why doesn't her faith make her feel that kind of joy?
I’m not so sure this is a good idea when she is feeling guilty. Whenever I got “down” like this, my husband would invite me along with whatever brothers were doing something festive. It always increased the guilt. I remember one time when I was so far gone in self-pity that, sitting at a restaurant table with my husband and another six or eight “brothers in good standing,” I punished myself by not ordering anything and suppressing tears. A skeleton at the feast, for damnsure.
The “Bible candy” approach may work better. Keep your ears open at your own church for scriptures about “God’s love for us sinners” and quote them, without embellishment, to your wife. Isn’t there one in Romans 8 about nothing being able to separate us from the love of God?
Circling back to sweetstuff’s idea, though:
…tell her how much you loved seeing her happy and having fun, andwhydoesn't her faith make her feel that kind of joy?
Don’t ever put her on the defensive by attacking the truth – for that is how she will see it. If you challenge “Jehovah” for not making her happy, of course she will have to defend him to you. But if you gently ask her if “Jehovah” is making her as happy as a night on the town – well, she may say yes, but just being asked will make it a little harder to lie to herself. That’s how it worked for me.
I remember reading a novel by Sherri Tepper, in which god appears to the people as a majestic fountain of abundance toward the end of the book, strewing the fruits of the land and the sea as he passed by. And as I read it, I caught myself thinking: “Why can’t my God do that?” This was five or ten years before I left, and I squelched the thought – but it did its healing work way down where I couldn’t see it.
That’s the kind of subversive inspiration you want to keep on tap.
gentlyferal