Ok Gotcha here's a more serious reply.. (not that I wasn't serious before, but the last message was not as serious as the first) From what I've observed it's interesting that spiritual teachers, (ones I believe can actually be considered such) as well as teachers of internal martial arts (which is related but certainly not the same) actually tell you very little. If you do your research you'll find the info, but the approach appears to be questions aimed at whether you have actually gotten the point of the practice, the instructions are very basic. (basically, meditate) Frankly the reason for it is simply so you'll come to naturally discover certain things for yourself. After all, if they say more than you need to know you might very well convince yourself of having some experience whether you actually had it or not. Critics will often turn around and say "ohh, it's so secretive - reminds me of a cult." Well, ok but the difference is they're not preaching anything, the people I'm describing leave it up to you to decide whether you might be able to learn anything from them. (you can also leave whenever you want, there's no social pressure - in fact you need to muster up some of your own resolve which is usually referred to as discipline) People having the short attention span that they do and glued to their world views as they are just tend to not stick it out or pay too much attention to what's there - whether pro or con people tend to focus more on their question rather than what's actually in front of them. Anyhow, perhaps the key here and the important thing in light of our shared JW heritage (I say that jokingly, certainly too strong a word for me anyway) is that whatever people tell you, if they allow room for you to find out for yourself then that's probably a healthy approach, but if it's an authoritarian approach of Joe Bob here has the truth and you should listen to him, it's probably not. At the very least, you won't know if Joe has the truth because you're just accepting that blindly rather than doing something to test that yourself.