I am so glad you brought up this topic, Mr. Flipper.
I too have noticed such comments and do not believe in disparaging any honest days work that anyone does to earn a living! We are all certainly not born with the same apptitudes or opportunities in life.
I know a number of VERY wealthy brothers and sisters who own their own janitorial, window washing, and lawn maintenance businesses. A relative of mine has retired early, a millionaire, from his landscaping maintainance business that grew and grew into major commercial and government contracts.
My husband and I own our own business and often needed to hire cleaners and window washers. At the prices they charged, I said forget it, that is almost as much as we are making and our business was struggling. I told my husband, it is not rocket science, we will do it ourself. While it was hard work, I told my husband, if our business does not work out, this would not be a bad way to make money. Very lucrative. I think one of the reasons that clearners and window washers were so busy and could charge so much and get it, in our town, is that so many people do subtly look down on cleaning as beneath them and refuse to consider this line of work, leaving a small number of operators without any competition and able to charge top dollar!
Well, I am not proud, it may not be a "skilled trade" but after seeing how poorly some cleaners clean, I would say that cleaning "well" does require a skill that many people do not possess!
I also know, many of the comments were intended not as digs at cleaners, but they certainly came across that way. The focus should be on the WTBTS's policy of not allowing people to pursue higher education, advanced degrees, or certain professions that expose one to a high degree of worldy philosophy or power, presitige, or autonomy of decision making. It is interesting, that even the cleaners and window washers who had become very wealthy were still criticized in the congregation, now for being too materialistic. (I think this was just jealousy, plain and simple).
Bottom line: it is important to choose our words carefully so that we do not become guilty of displaying the same sort of judgementalism and superiority, narrowmindedness that we accuse the WTBTS of. Similiar to "reverse racism".
Great thread!
Cog