If you knew how the meat you eat was slaughtered, would you still eat it?

by restrangled 63 Replies latest jw friends

  • funkyderek
    funkyderek

    momzcrazy:

    Goddamnit! How am I supposed to debate you with those things pointing at me?!

    (Shielding my eyes)

    I'm sorry, how does the way I treat MY animals and kids affect starving kids and slaughtered animals?

    Well, money you spend on them is money that you could donate to charity, for example. (Not saying you should, just that you could.)

    How are starving children fed by not slaughtering animals?

    It's more efficient (for the most part) for humans to eat crops directly rather than feed them to animals and then eat the animals. The superabundance of cheap food that would be available if everyone switched to a plant-based diet would easily feed the world's starving people.

    Why am I being attacked because I do eat animals and feed my kids animals?

    Not attacking you, just pointing out that you do actually compare children to animals and, like virtually every other person in the world (including me) you care more for those near you than for distant, nameless statistics. I don't mean to pick on you specifically, just to highlight the incongruity between giving regular insulin shots to a cat, and eating the flesh of another mammal that never even saw daylight in its short miserable existence. If you're comfortable with doing that, then that's fine but if you expect to be involved in a discussion about how we treat animals and not have someone question how you treat animals, then you're in the wrong place.

    Is it because I don't object to them being slaughtered for meat?

    No, it's to make sure you know how they live and how they die so you can make an informed decision.

    I can't change how animals are treated. I can only have an effect what I buy and how I treat animals here.

    What you buy can change how animals are treated. If you only buy free-range organic meat (for example - the whole labelling system can be an ethical minefield) you are ensuring that your money only goes to those who treat animals (relatively) well. You can make a difference - if you choose to.

    BurnTheShips:

    “When men stop believing in God they don’t believe in nothing; they believe in anything."

    Never been accused of that before. I don't think I believe anything about animals that you don't. I just think it's more ethical to treat them better.

    One wonders if he tears off a tick or a flea.

    If I can remove a parasite without killing it, I will, but I really have no ethical issue with bug-squishing.

    hillbilly:

    Momz... the funksters at that stage of life where debate for the sake of debate is fun for him. He is a pretty bright kid most of the time.

    I think I'll put a positive spin on that and say it makes me feel young, rather than see it as condescending.

  • Deputy Dog
    Deputy Dog

    restrangled

    What is more likley to make me sick, are groups like this mercyforanimals.org. What were you doing there? They want to give animals the same rights as people. Next they will try to make you sick from eating the trout you catch or the deer you shoot. But lets not talk about a preborn child, abortion does make me sick.

  • momzcrazy
    momzcrazy
    Well, money you spend on them is money that you could donate to charity, for example. (Not saying you should, just that you could.)

    Can and do. My girls sponser two girls their same age in Guatamala.

    What you buy can change how animals are treated. If you only buy free-range organic meat (for example - the whole labelling system can be an ethical minefield) you are ensuring that your money only goes to those who treat animals (relatively) well. You can make a difference - if you choose to.

    Do that too. Also eat wild game that I know has been killed humanely. Instant death with a shot to the back of the head. Damn $600 scope for a birthday ensures that one!

    Not attacking you, just pointing out that you do actually compare children to animals and, like virtually every other person in the world (including me) you care more for those near you than for distant, nameless statistics.

    I guess saying I "baby" my dogs threw this one off track. If I cared for my dogs the same way I cared for my kids, my dogs would have their own rooms with private baths. They would never have to ask for anything because they get everything already. BUT as they are animals that I chose to bring into my home and be responsible for, I am now in charge of caring for them as animals. Key word animals. They have a dog house for each of them. They eat well and get walked everyday. And they sleep in our garage at night. My cat gets insulin because I wasn't going to put down a great mouser for something easily treated.

    Do you see the difference between my kids and my animals? I agree that animals should be treated humanely. I don't agree with how they were handled in that video.

    But I still take the stand that animals are animals. They are a lower life form than humans.

    God, I wish I hadn't failed debate in High School!

    momz (who thinks it is too early in the day for this!)

  • R.Crusoe
    R.Crusoe

    HillBilly there is no way you had that for dinner OMG!

    I am vegitarian but got hoodwinked a week ago with a potatoe and meat pastie (about %10) which tasted very nice but wasnt why I ate it = I just was in company and completely zoned out so first meat I ate in maybe two years!

    My reason = none except my inner slef! I will always spell self as slef cuz a woman I never met is a witch and maybe the most amazing human I never met always spelt it just so!

    Trust me = her mind will bed your mind any time!! And not just sexual!!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit