Dearest Teej... peace and happy Hanukkah, Xmas, New Year, Solstice, poultice, and whatever other 'holiday' you may 'celebrate', too!
Dearest Rex... peace to you and my apologies for taking so long to respond. For some reason, jw.com does not have the 'intrigue' for me that it had... and so I've been away for a bit (not that I am 'back', but just wanted to respond, if I may).
Sorry Shelby, you missed the mark again. Too many scriptures and not enough scriptural interpretation.
Actually, Rex, while I did cite many Bible verses, not many of them were 'scripture'. Be that as it may, if you are who YOU are, and the Bible is, as you believe, God's WORD... what interpretation do you need from ME? Does not all interpretation belong to God? Why, then, do you not ask Him... rather that rely on me... for interpretation? No, I think it is you who has "missed the mark" on this one.
Anyone can post numerous generalized scripture pulled totally out of context in order to avoid answering specific questions.
I posted scripture and verse that substantiated what I spoke to you. I purposefully did NOT interpret them... for that would have been just what you decry... MY interpretation. If you read them, though (yeah, right, sure), and yet did not 'get the sense' of them, am I to blame? Cannot your 'god' interpret them for you? Mine can... and did... by means of His Son.
Hebrews 1:2
My word, you don't even rcognize similes and metaphors as such.
Well, okay... call me 'uneducated'. No matter; I've been called worse.
You ignore the principle that scripture cannot contradict itself when you use single scripture exgesis.
Well, I would have to agree that 'scripture' cannot contradict itself; however, since I know the Bible not BE entirely 'scripture', and have read MANY verses that 'contradict' others, by means of the 'false stylus' of the copyists (i.e., translators), I think I have to disagree with your assumption, as YOU assume the entire Bible to be 'scripture'. Which is it not.
Are we cannibals?
Well, let's see... according to the Encarta Dictionary, a cannibal is:
1. somebody who eats human flesh: somebody who eats human flesh, whether as food or as part of a religious ritual
2. animal that eats its own species: an animal that eats the flesh of other animals of the same species
So, based on that, I would have to say no... we are not 'cannibals'. You were speaking of those of 'us' that eat meat, though, weren't you?
Oh boy, I cannot let this go!
Well, you CAN... but why would you want to?
I'm sorry to be so blunt, Shelby.
I do not find you 'blunt'. Ignorant, yes. Blunt, no.
You are just so misrepresenting God's word that I suspect you are a genuine cultist bent on deception and making a name for yourself, despite all of your alleged humility.
"Misrepresenting God's word..." No, I give the glory and credit to that One, as well as speak what he tells me. Now, if I gave such to myself or to another, or said something other than what he gave me to speak, indeed, I would be misrepresenting him. Oh, wait! You mean 'misrepresenting' the Bible?! Dear one, I think it is you that again is 'missing the mark'. I implore you, then: first, ascertain what... or rather who... in TRUTH... is God's Word... and then we will discuss who is 'misrepresenting' him. I'll wait for ya!
John 1:1; 1:14
Revelation 19:13
"quote from me: 'Animals act on instinct and with the minor tricks that man can teach them.' Shelby: Job 39:9 (Actually, ALL of Job 39); Job 41:3, 4
Your assertion of 'instinct' is simply support of a contrivance of 'earthling' man, to explain what they do not understand.
They do not know good or bad.
You, then, have never owned a dog. Nor have you read research on primates. Nor have you read the account of Balaam's ass. Try both; see if you get a 'clearer' understanding of this issue.
They are not share any spirit with us, they have no immortal soul and scriptures teach that they are a lower creation.
Okay, now who's REALLY missing the mark here? I showed where the Bible (God's WORD, according to you), says we have but one spirit, we and the beasts, and that we do not KNOW if they 'go' where we do when they die, AND... there is no 'superiority' of man over the beast. Yes? And yet... YOU say... ah, nevermind.
And in response to Job, you state:
Where???????What??????Instinct is the key word, God gave them that.
Obviously, you read neither account. Go back and do so, and we will speak on this again. In the meantime, may I ask you: what would be the POINT in God giving "Leviathan" the ability to "make entreaties" to Him? And do you know what it means to MAKE entreaties, dear Rex?
"Shelby: Just because they are 'dumb' and exist in different bodies does not mean they cannot... and do not... worship God.
Rex: Oh boy! Is that some divine revelation from your 'a god' Shelby?
Well, yeah. Were it not 'divine revelation', it would be something I myself contrived, yes? Me, imperfect flesh. And yet, I did not lie to you, but spoke truth. You DO know from whom 'truth' originates, don't you, Rex?
"From Shelby: See citations from Job, above, please." Rex:
What??????Where??????
A-b-o-v-e, Rex. As in stated PREVIOUSLY herein... and BEFORE this... yada, yada, yada...
"Shelby: We can use them for food, but we CANNOT abuse them."
Rex: So by your reasoning we are cannibals.
Your reading comprehension... or lack thereof... is showing, Rex. See the dictionary explanation for 'cannibal'... a-b-o-v-e... as in toward the beginning of this response, as in before this.
How do animals worship God, Shelby?
In the same was we do/can, Rex.
Not in any literal sense does this occur, for man is a distinct and higher creation.
Actually, you are in error. YOU apparently ascribe the 'form of worship' that 'earthling' man interprets as praying, going to church, singing hymns, knocking on doors, attending meetings, observing the Eucharist, etc. HOWEVER... God is a SPIRIT! And for HIM, those who 'worship' Him MUST 'worship' Him... in SPIRIT. And truth! Animals have spirits, Rex, and so can worship God through such spirit. And unlike HUMANS... animals don't lie, deceive, cheat, etc. But the PUREST form of worshipping God is done MORE by animals than by 'earthling' man. It is called... OBEDIENCE.
When my Father, who feeds the sparrows, sends out His call to His animal creation... they... for the MOST part... 'hear'... and obey. May I ask you, what brought Elijah food in the wilderness? WHO TOLD IT TO DO SO? And WHY did it do so? Try reading Revelation 19:17, which WAS inspired, Rex.
I am sorely tempted to expose the rest of your post line by line but I have not yet acquired that much patience.
And how is that, Rex? Is not patience a 'fruit' of God's spirit? And if it is YOU that is a 'son' of God, do you not possess such spirit, or can at least ask and receive it? Why then do you not simply ASK for it... I mean, so that you can 'expose' me?
Luke 11:13
Then you perpetuate the Gnostic heresy and deny the tranformation of Jesus as man and portray Him as spiritual only.
Again, you miss the mark. Indeed, my Lord was... and IS a man. First, in the flesh; last in the spirit. He is no longer flesh with its blood, for such flesh was 'sown in corruption' and 'raised up in incorruption.' It was sown a physical body and raised up a spiritual one. And a SPIRIT body can 'possess' any physical vessel it chooses. Indeed, if DEMONS can do it, how is the One who has 'all authority in heaven and on earth', UNABLE to do it?
Let's see, gnosticism, arianism and what other debunked heresies do you hold to?
I do not know from 'arianism' (will look it up, though), but 'gnosticism' is based on knowledge, and the belief the knowledge is what leads to life. To the contrary, I know that eating the 'tree of knowledge of good and bad' is what led to DEATH... and I have no part with such one. Rather, I 'eat' from the Tree... of LIFE. And it is 'knowing' THAT One... and by connection... knowing GOD... that I live... and will yet live. Incorruptibly and eternally.
One other thing my dear, are the H2O poster formerly known as Sis4Jah and Renee on other forums?
I do not know of whom you speak, Rex. Truthfully. I remember seeing the first one post, but cannot recall the latter one at all. But neither are me, nor do I know either of them... personally or otherwise.
My peace remains...
Your servant, and a slave of Christ,
SJ