The Nothing Man:
I consider them inappropiate, won't do anything for current Witnesses curious about the truth about the truth if they see gay dating adverts on this site; it will just strengnthen their resolve that Apostates are bad.
What if they're gay? They may be delighted to see that we're not at all like the irrational bigots in the Watchtower.
I don't visit here much, and I know this point will be contested, what with so many 'open minded' people on here, but I think it dents our operation in helping people see the truth.
Then for your part in the operation, you can choose not to host such advertising. A wise old apostate once told me that his methods were vilified by other apostates for being too hostile. They preferred the softly-softly approach which undoubtedly worked for some people and were concerned that his hate-filled invective would scare people off, which it probably did. But at least some JWs became so apoplectic with rage about hearing their beloved religion ridiculed so abusively that they resolved to prove him wrong, but after expending considerable time and effort to do so, found that everything he had written was in fact correct, and as a result they left the religion. The fact is we don't know exactly what will attract curious JWs and what will turn them off, and I for one refuse to compromise myself or my views on the basis that somebody might become offended. This is what the world outside the Watchtower walls is like, and it serves no purpose to pretend otherwise.