Hi all--it's been awhile since posting on the forum. Welcome to Little Red Birdie, too.
I had a similar experience while in high school as peaceloveharmony expressed. I enjoyed my "worldly" friends a lot, and I fell head-over-heels in love with a Catholic girl my junior year. I'm grateful for that bit of a normal life as a JW youth.
I think many of us with Web sites receive posts from folks like LRB, and older people regularly. JWs appear normal (well except for You Know & Fredhall) and many are attracted to the well trimmed and/or modest look presented by some Witnesses. Also, many JWs limit their sexual behavior to kissing and petting (except when Kent was a JW) outside of marriage. Qualities some find appealing. It's only after an outsider is into a relationship with a JW that they see how loony the religion really is. This in turn generates numerous inquires from the "I'm in love with a JW, but..." category.
Timothy Campbell created an interesting link called "I'm In Love with a Jehovah's Witness!" because of the inquires he received. It's at http://members.aol.com/beyondjw/inlove.htm That site might be helpful to you, LRB.