Jonah's under water stomach vacation....a biblical fact ?

by Homerovah the Almighty 31 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Homerovah the Almighty
    Homerovah the Almighty
    Jonah’s Underwater Stomach Vacation

    By capella

    Once upon a time there was a man named Jonah who was traveling to Nineveh on a ship when along came a mighty wind which rocked the ship violently, scaring the pee pee out of everyone on board except for Jonah who like many Biblical figures in various Bible stories had passed out.

    The brave sailors of the ship started to panic and began throwing things overboard. Meanwhile Jonah awakened with a hangover, went on top, and convinced the sailors that if they threw him overboard the storm would stop and sure enough it worked.

    Then, as if things weren’t going badly enough for Jonah, along came a “big fish” which swallowed him.

    After three days of living underwater inside of the fish’s stomach it occurred to Jonah to pray. After some fast talking God spoke to the fish (in fisheese) and the fish vomited Jonah onto land where he scampered off to preach to the people of Nineveh.

    Can anyone reading identify some of the problems with this story? Let’s see how well you did:

    Oxygen

    Jonah, without scuba gear and hence without oxygen, survived inside of a fish’s stomach underwater for three days. A lesser man would have suffocated within minutes, but apparently Jonah was exceptionally good at holding his breath?

    Digestive Juices

    The environment of the stomach is not a very pleasant place. Not the sort of place you would want to take your girlfriend on the first date. Stomachs are dark, smelly, and full of nasty digestive juices which curiously are meant to digest things over time that the fish has swallowed such as for example, Jonah.

    Water

    Also in stomachs, potable water is very scarce. In fact there is generally no potable water at all. The only thing available for drinking is just poisonous digestive juices. Human males require 3.7 liters of water a day to survive. In fact after three days of not drinking water Jonah would have at least been very close to dying from lack of water alone. Certainly in no condition to walk to Nineveh.

  • DaCheech
    DaCheech

    selective miracles are great arent they?

  • Jim_TX
    Jim_TX

    That story was stolen from Pinochio.

    Wooden puppets do not need water.

    Regards,

    Jim TX

  • VM44
    VM44

    Did the original writer of the Jonah story really expect later generations to consider his story as fact rather than fiction?

    What was the author's real purpose in writing the story?

  • mkr32208
    mkr32208

    Sure they did VM they saw these giant ass whales and such and being one step removed from baboons they assumed that they were full of air and a person could survive in there! Check your mythological database people used to get swallowed by whales all the damn time! Hell whole ships complete with crews got swallowed!

    Of course a fundy will tell you that simply PROVES that the jonah story is correct. What it really does prove is that anyone who believes this shit needs a lobotomy!

  • mkr32208
    mkr32208

    Second point! A whales throat is actually pretty small isn't it? Most whales eat krill and similar so don't have a 'man sized' esophagus!

    Also shouldn't god have KNOWN that whales weren't fish? I mean they probably didn't have a word for 'mammal' vs 'big fish' but shouldn't god have said something?

  • inkling
    inkling

    Let me put on my faith googles, and correct a few mistakes you made:

    Oxygen

    Jonah, without scuba gear and hence without oxygen, due to a miracle survived inside of a fish’s stomach underwater for three days. A lesser man would have suffocated within minutes, but apparently Jonah was exceptionally good at holding his breath? praying for a miracle.

    Digestive Juices

    The environment of the stomach is not a very pleasant place. Untill a miracle happens. And which point it becomes awesome.

    Water

    Also in stomachs, potable water is very scarce. Therefore, It's a good thing God decided to miracle some into existance just by thinking it.

    There you go, all better now.

    [inkling]

  • Homerovah the Almighty
    Homerovah the Almighty

    The latter part of the story is as follows after the whale spat out Jonah on to shore , Jonah wiped him self off and began to shake his fist at the great whale and swore at him in Hebrew.

    in return the whale just winked at Jonah and swam off.

    Dam why don't these things happen today ?

  • Farkel
    Farkel

    homerovah,

    You missed another great part of the story. Jonah went back to Ninevah (where he should have gone in the first place, before he became a chickenshit and tried to get away) and preached to them, just as God told him to do.

    And guess what? Ninevah repented! Jehovah spared them. And Jonah was really pissed off! He wanted God kill him anyway, because being the wonderful guy that Jonah was, he wanted in his heart of hearts for God to massacre the whole lot of them!

    The story of Ninevah just like the story of Job, makes one wonder why God is screwing around with non Jews in ancient times. Oh, by the way, if you read the whole delicious account, when Jonah "walked around" Ninevah, he must have walked about a jillion miles. The Bible tells us that the city of Ninevah was about the size of Texas, or even Alaska. (Slight exaggeration here.)

    I swear I am not making this up. I like the way Thomas Paine described this fable. He said a big fish swallowing a man was nothing spectacular as miracles go. But Jonah swallowing the big fish would have been a real miracle!

    Farkel

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia

    Well, my favorite part is the fact that even the oxen and horses of the city by order of the king wore sackcloth in repentance for their sins -- a humorous touch to be sure. Another is that the king was the last one get the news about wearing sackcloth (which everyone from greatest to least were doing) and he issued a proclamation to the citizens to do something they were already all doing!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit