On the matter of male good looks, I've had it proven to me several times that I'm no judge of them. There's no physical attraction there, so I take a detached view; but invariably the guys I assume are probably attractive turn out to be dog-ugly to women, and the ones I think are disgusting are the hunks.
Case in point: I had told a girlfriend on more than one occasion, in the course of various conversations, "I'm no judge of male good looks." Then one day she and her two teenage daughters were talking about Billy Ray Cyrus, and I commented, "I don't get it. That guy is just downright ugly." There was a long, pregnant pause, and then my girlfriend said, "Fred, you're right... you really don't know anything about male good looks."
COMF