La Vey Satanism, or something else?
I apparently don't follow "the pattern" that CRR puts out.
My advice: stop trying so hard. If you want a relationship, that takes time and grows. You can't force it - the things you force like that turn ugly.
Get involved in hobbies - there are clubs, meetings, events, humans are endlessly devising ways to participate in things they enjoy or find interesting, and show off their interests and passions. Look at the local indie/alternate press for events and like-minded others. Get out and meet people. Go to church, if you really are making a specific religion a focal point of your life.
You'll *meet people*. And they'll be sharing in something you're also interested in. That's how things usually start.
A problem with much "forced" dating is the incessant need to keep a conversation going, which makes all manner of stupid trivial verbiage come rushing out. Don't be so hard on your date, they're probably just nervous and don't know what to say. They just might have an IQ of 156 but don't want to intimidate you.
Be yourself. If that happens to attract others, great; if not, change (you've started that by emerging from the krazy kult). If you attract people you don't like by pretending to be someone else, well, that would be "your problem".
You can have your standards. In the end, people will meet them, or you'll choose to be more alone. Or you can compromise.
If you want to fall in love, that won't happen on a time table. And if you fall in love, you won't care if they aren't brilliant or picture perfect.