Who’s smarter, Catholics or J.W.’s?

by wheelwithinwheel 26 Replies latest jw friends

  • wheelwithinwheel
    wheelwithinwheel

    As I was growing up my dad would always make a special effort to enlighten his Catholic brother-in-law. He’d ask my uncle to get out his Catholic Bible and show him scriptures. One of his favourite arguments was the doctrine of the Pope’s infallability. Dad would ask “How can a reasonable person believe a mere human is infallible?” Another subject that was rehashed many times was the trinity. Dad would always comment the math aspect and ask “How is it possible to add 1+1+1 and get 1 for an answer. My uncle would listen, just smile and remark, “You’re dwelling on details”. These details seemed unimportant to him.

    My uncle was baptised Catholic, learned Catholic doctrine and will be having a Catholic funeral. I don’t believe my uncle ever imagined the Pope was perfect and I don’t think he worried excessively about the trinity being true or not. He led his life by his personal principles, taking into consideration his faith when he felt it appropriate and ignoring Church doctrine he disagreed with.

    My dad, on the other hand, would often say the G.B were not infallible. He would tell us the group was made up of imperfect men that made mistakes. But it never seemed to occur to him to question their ideas or math. He believed, obeyed and planned his life around them. When he receives the April 15 th Watchtower concerning “this generation” he will once again adjust his thinking and his math to conform to the new light. Of course, he’s quite used to math-adjusting by this time. The strange thing is, it just occurred to me, that the latest 1+1=1 is bringing him closer to the 1+1+1=1 that he once argued impossible.

    So the April Watchtower got me to thinking: Who’s more intelligent?

    The Catholics? Their church tells them their leader is infallible and 1+1+1=1. But the Catholics don’t seem to believe it or worry about it and certainly don’t plan their life accordingly.

    Or the J.W.’s? Their church tells them their leaders are merely imperfect men. And now they teach 1+1=1. But the J.W.’s seem to accept and believe every word coming out of their church’s mouths. They make sure to keep their ideas in line with the latest church thoughts and are even willing to bet their lives on them.

    wheels turning…

  • shamus100
    shamus100

    Catholics by far.

  • FreudianSlip
    FreudianSlip

    First, the 1+1+1=1 argument is lame. They think of it more lie a pie, yes, it might be cut into three slices, but it's still one pie. But I digress. If we are talking IQ, I think both group's members are probably on equal footing. I do, however, believe that Catholics on average are probably more knowledge about the world. They don't insulate themselves and they don't discourage higher education.

  • SirNose586
    SirNose586
    First, the 1+1+1=1 argument is lame. They think of it more lie a pie, yes, it might be cut into three slices, but it's still one pie. But I digress. If we are talking IQ, I think both group's members are probably on equal footing. I do, however, believe that Catholics on average are probably more knowledge about the world. They don't insulate themselves and they don't discourage higher education.

    But then they'd get all upset: "So now God's a fraction now??"

  • FreudianSlip
    FreudianSlip

    Each piece of the pie is one slice, put them together it's one pie. I'm no Catholic apologist, that's just how I've had it explained to me.

    Catholics also use this one a lot..

    “You’re dwelling on details”. These details seemed unimportant to him.

    .. if you ask too many questions. I've always considered it a copout in the past.. but maybe they have a point. No one will be able to address all of the minutae related to their religion.

  • OUTLAW
    OUTLAW

    Jehovah`s Witness`s would`nt have a Bible without the Catholics..

    The name Jehovah is a 14th century Translation Mistake made by a Catholic Monk..

    Without the Catholics..

    Jehovah`s Witness`s would`nt have a Bible or,a Name for thier God and Religion..

    ........................ ...OUTLAW

  • sir82
    sir82

    Well, Catholics encourage their kids to get an education beyond high school, as opposed to JWs who encourage "pioneering" or "Bethel".

    I think you can figure it out from there.

  • JWoods
    JWoods

    Also, the Catholic Church has a far superior artwork and musical record to the JWs.

  • mama1119
    mama1119

    I grew up JW...with Catholic influences..and my husband and I are going through the RCIA processs to become full fledged Catholics. The process is almost a year long, with weekly classes. I have never learned so much about God, Jesus, Mary, the bible, christian history when I was in the JW. I don't just mean the Catholic beliefs, but history, facts, all that. I actually now feel I have biblical knowledge, and I never felt that way in the JW. I don't think Catholics are smarter..thats just too general, but they promote eduction within the church alot more. My kids are enrolled in Religious Ed, and they are learning a ton.

  • Think About It
    Think About It

    Who is smarter.......the Catholic who converted to JW or the Catholic who converted to JW, then left JW?

    Think About It

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit