So, Who Really DOES Write the WT? ( A LONG But Worthy Post)

by AGuest 23 Replies latest jw friends

  • moshe
    moshe

    Lets see if I understand this. The GB, aka, part of the F&DS ceded control of the writing of the WatchTower literature to the brothers who weren't anointed back around 1972-75. They re-write and reformulate WT articles and then run them through the filter of Old WT teachings ( not sure how far back that goes). Anything which does not compute or match up goes to the trash can. If they do decide they want to make a change in current teachings they run it by the GB for approval. BUT, if it is something totally new, then they can print it without any input from the GB.

    Strangely, it seems the writing department can promulgate an entirely new doctrine, then after it is printed it become the defacto "law" for JW's. However, I think, if the writing department realizes later that they made a big blunder and want to change or do away with their new dogma, they must then receive approval from the GB in order to do so. Sounds like a catch 22 for them and the only sure thing for the JWs is that they will keep digging a deeper pit of weirdness for themselves.

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    You got it, dear Moshe! Peace to you!

    A slave of Christ,

    SA (who apologizes for the long post - well, this one...)

  • agonus
    agonus

    So I guess the short answer is "who the hell knows"?

  • not a captive
    not a captive

    Thanks for the interest, friends. I will be glad to post the correspondence between myself and the Organization. I will find a way to --scan it?

    For me, the interesting retrospective on it is the progressive way that a mind can thread its may out of captivity when it does hang on to a single thread. I say it took a year to get out. But the beginning started long before that. I don't expect everyone to come to the same conclusion I do but no one can "unconconvince" me--certainly the Branch didn't. I told the brothers that whether or not I was right or wrong in my conclusions I had to stand before God with my conscience and they were wrong to compel me or anyone against--even the Organizations own references!

    The reason I've been off the board is my job ends today. I take care of a great little boy with severe disabilities. I love him. There have been a lot of closing details to deal with and I wasn't able to check the thread.

    Good idea about starting another thread on this.

    Maeve

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit