How To Properly Interpret The Watchtower Society

by metatron 13 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    I have a long history in this cult, at various levels. A few of you, out there in cyberspace, share a similar experience - but many do not.

    I'm going to tell you how to interpret things that happen in the organization, as well as what is written in the magazines.

    It's not terribly difficult because they are so reactionary. A fellow Bethelite corrected me on this point when I accused them of being fascists. "Nope, just reactionaries", he said. He was right.

    So, if you hear and read a burst of coincidental appeals for contributions ( which happened right after they started the 'voluntary donation' disaster), you may fairly conclude that they need cash and want you to open your wallets. Very simple.

    And college? They observe wreckage from kids going to college and never looking back at the 'truth'. So, they 'bang away', preaching against college.

    If you are an elder, remember how they keep pounding away at 'not being alone with a woman/sister'? Why do you think? Too many elders whipping out their Johnsons ( or 'John Thomases', for you Brits).

    If they publish articles about examining if you are really of the 'anointed', you know that they are irked by so many upstarts partaking.

    All of which brings me to a critical point: Endless nagging is NOT a sign of strength, but rather of desperation. If you think otherwise, consider the disadvantaged position of parents who do so. They wring their hands and tell you 'they don't know what else to do'.

    Exactly!

    What some of you interpret as 'tightening up' or 'cracking down', I see as weakness. They don't know what else to do. In particular, they find that they are increasingly 'hemmed in', constrained, limited in how they can react - because the world is turning away from a Bible-related culture into one that is purely secular, as in France. Even if they are safe from court interference, they still must 'play nice' (hypocritically) for EU and UN bureaucrats, as "poor, persecuted victims" while ignoring human rights within the organization. Their naked lies about the blood transfusion issue in regard to Bulgaria may have backfired on them, pushing them away from enforcement.

    They were wary of talking about homosexual relations at assemblies because they felt local gay rights groups were monitoring them. They must be careful about holidays and more because of child custody cases. They KNOW they are being watched.

    Talks given at district assemblies are monitored by assigned brothers from Bethel to make sure no one says anything 'off script'.

    Let them rail against the internet and college and Facebook and more. The more they nag, the weaker they are and the less they can actually do. While shunning relatives is a problem for us, it is also a big problem for them or they wouldn't keep nagging about it.

    metatron

  • garyneal
    garyneal

    Interesting take...

  • inbetween
    inbetween

    sounds about right, the whole structur contributes to that, elders report to CO, CO and DO report to the branch, branch to headquarter, writing department is assigned with corresponding articles....its all reaction, no divine revelation, or at least real leadership....

  • LV101
    LV101

    metatron: great info --- desperation? hope you are right and it continues to consume them.

    what a stupid religion. i've known so many people over the yrs. (even gals i used to give the magazines to) who've indicated they would visit a hall or go along w/friends, family, if they weren't SUCH A CULT! many are scared of this religion. they've reaped what they've sown --- IDIOTS!

  • meangirl
    meangirl

    Interesting. Makes sense.

  • RayPublisher
    RayPublisher

    Metatron- good points. It is an example of the "tail wagging the dog". They keep tabs on everything- you woudn't believe the tacking of nmbers and staistics that goes on at Bethel. Ray Franze made reference to it on COC, and I saw it when I was there. They would make you feel guilty if you dropped a plate and broke it when doing dish duty.

    "There goes little Jimmy's $1.23 contibution!"

    It's all calculated like a politician watching the polls.

  • godrulz
    godrulz

    Authoritarian structures give uniformity, but at great cost. True Christianity has true unity despite diversity without the control-freak issues of men. We who are led by the Spirit and have the Word do not need fallible, hypocritical humans micromanaging our lives and the life of the church. True elders are servant leaders with wisdom, not puppets of an organization trying to control people. In light of the plethora of information to bring the WT down, I am amazed people fall for it or remain in it.

  • DagothUr
    DagothUr

    That is the problem with every authoritarian system. This type of system has only one way to manage all it's flaws: tighten the grip! But nothing can be tightened forever and one day the system cracks and then explodes.

  • sir82
    sir82
    They don't know what else to do.

    Exactly!

    What else do you expect when creativity is viewed with suspicion & mistrust...."harrumph....well, that's not the way the Watchtower says to do it....that's not the way we did it in [1968 / my old congregation / when Brother OldSchool was CO]....we aren't a [fill-in-the-blank] organization, our job is to preach..."

    Bold new innovative ideas are not welcome. And so they continue to clunk along, with meeting formats virtually unchanged since the 1940's, preaching methods virtually unchanged since the 1940's, organizational hierarchy virtually unchanged since the 1940's, roundly condemning pretty much any new technology invented since the 1940's....

    And they wonder why the kids get fed up and leave.

  • godrulz
    godrulz

    Well, they do have a website.... what is CO? (carbon monoxide in my world)

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit