Boy Denied Communion Because of Cerebral Palsy

by whereami 26 Replies latest jw friends

  • whereami
    whereami

    Can't you just feel the love!!!! Kevin Castro's Grandmother Calls Priest's Offer of Annointing of Sick 'Offensive'

    A Catholic church turned away 8-year-old Kevin Castro of Floresville, Texas, from his First Communion because he had cerebral palsy, according to the boy's family.

    When the Rev. Phil Henning of Sacred Heart Catholic Church denied Kevin his first reception of the Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist, Henning said the boy had "the mental capacity of a 6-month old" and didn't have "sufficient knowledge of Christ" to participate in the religious rite, even though Catholic doctrine doesn't specify what level of knowledge is adequate.

    Kevin's grandmother, Irma Castro, said Kevin had prepared for months for the "religious milestone" only to be offered a ritual for those who are sick.

    "That is the anointing they give you before death," his grandmother told ABC's affiliate KSAT. "That was very offensive."

    Kevin's family cried "discrimination."

    Cerebral palsy can include any number of neurological disorders that appear in infancy or early childhood and permanently affect body movement and muscle coordination but don't worsen over time, according to the National Institutes of Health.

    It is the most common motor disorder in children and is second only to autism as the most common disability in children, according to United Cerebral Palsy, an organization that provides education and support for people with a spectrum of disabilities. Each year about 10,000 babies born in the United States will develop cerebral palsy, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It affects boys more frequently than girls.

    Cerebral palsy, though, is not always associated with intellectual disability. "It's not the same as intellectual disability, and it does not cause intellectual disability," said Chris Thomson, general counsel for UCP. "Individuals who have cerebral palsy can also have intellectual disability. But one does not cause the other and they are separate conditions."

    It can, however, come with its share of misunderstanding and discrimination, like the kind Kevin Castro experienced in his church.

    "Faith is an important part of people's lives, and we hope that his church and family can find a solution that allows Kevin to be an active and full participant of his faith community," said Stephen Bennett, president and CEO of UCP. "UCP is committed to full citizenship for people with disabilities, regardless of the severity and expression."

    "Without knowing [Kevin's] medical diagnosis, it is impossible to know what he may be experiencing," said Thomson. "But people often mistakenly confuse cerebral palsy for an intellectual disability because of the symptoms they witness, such a slurred speech, drooling or spasticity."

    Irma Castro said that she had been helping to prepare Kevin for months for his communion, and the priest's decision had shaken her faith. "I hurt for my grandson and my family," she said.

    First Communion Is Important Rite

    The important ceremony means the child has been embraced by the church community. and it is accompanied by traditional family celebrations and gifts.

    Deacon Pat Rodgers, from the Archdiocese of San Antonio, told ABCNews.com that the decision whether to give the sacrament lies with the local priest, but emphasized, "It's never our desire, hope or wish to withhold a sacrament from someone who wants or needs it."

    Henning's church offices were closed Tuesday, and he did not return messages left by ABCNews.com.

    http://abcnews.go.com/m/story?id=13461019&sid=26

  • lovelylil
    lovelylil

    They are a bunch of legalistic morons! Communion is about joining the faith community of the church. So are they rejecting this boy from that communiyt because he is disabled, saying he is not good enough to be part of the church? They have a lot of explaining to do. The mother says the boy was practicing for months, he obviously had a desire to do this. Things like this make me SO MAD at the church!

  • Scully
    Scully

    Wow. So loving. So Christ-like. If (and that seems to not be the case considering how the family helped to prepare him for the event) the boy is, in fact, unable to understand the basics of the belief system required to participate in communion, I would actually give the church credit for not shackling a child to a belief system he is incapable of understanding.

    I bet they let him have a christening, before he was capable of understanding the rite and its significance.

  • RADHESYAM
    RADHESYAM

    Thats DISGUSTING

    Isn't Lord Jesus full of UNCONDITIONAL LOVE?

  • lovelylil
    lovelylil

    While I understand the church's "official" position on this, the church should just bend the rules in this siutation. It is about making a young boy who wants to belong to the church feel like he is part of the faith community. A little common sense should have been applied here.

  • Scully
    Scully

    Lil,

    If this was a mentally challenged child of the JWs, would you encourage "bending of the rules" to let him be Baptized™ so he can feel like he belongs to his faith community?

    While I agree that the Catholic Church is a far cry from the JWs in terms of community inclusion/exclusion, I really feel that it is wrong to perform the rites of a belief system on an individual who doesn't have the capacity to understand the doctrines and requirements of the belief system.

  • lovelylil
    lovelylil

    scully,

    In my opinion you cannot compare the Catholic religion to that of the JW religion because the Catholics do not shun members who decide to stop attending church. Also the JW's do not have a "faith community" in any real sense. They belong to a legalistic cult of mainstream chrisitianity that is more concerned with the members obeying thier rules than with fostering community within its ranks.

    So NO I would not feel the same way about this if it were a mentally challenged jw kid. That is my opinion as a mainstream christian who also grew up in the Catholic church and was a JW for a decade. I am viewing this from my experience on all sides of the issue. While You are also entitled to your opinions you must know you and I will never agree on this one.

  • Band on the Run
    Band on the Run

    My brother has cerebral palsy! Only last night I was reading about cp and crying my heart out. He's had it almost 60 years but it is so unfair. This thead has me in tears. The audacity to stand between Christ and a human. Christ is definitely suffering with the boy and happy with his joys. Dorothy Sayers, the mystery writer, wrote a short story about a severely mentally retarded boy. God does not have our standards. Perhaps in God's view, mentally challenged is preferred. I grew up at the cerebral palsy center. We had fun.

    I became severely ill with facial pain. Church was mainly a social, intellectual occasion for me. Fortunately, I had the ties when my trial started. The suicide rate is 95%. Most churches welcomed me with open arms and much love. I became ill when AIDS first struck Manhattan. A man with AIDS was denied admission to a public healing service at the Roman Catholic St. Patrick's Cathedral. I was desperate. Going to these services kept my hope and my self alive. I called St. Patrick's and spoke with a priest. When he heard I was not Roman Catholic, I was told I was not welcome. It is Christ's body, not the cardinal's body. I promised not to seek communion. No, I could not be present for prayers.

    The evangelicals have that affirmation, What would Jesus do? What would Jesus do, indeed? I have no doubt He is embracing that child. The New York Times ran the AIDS story on the front page. The church provided a private meeting for him. How many people have the NYT in their corner?

    Is there any way to write this mother a note of support without being intrusive?

  • lovelylil
    lovelylil

    Band, ((((hugs to you)))

    These type of things make me so angry at churches that claim they are Christ's but by their actions show they are not. Of course Jesus would not turn away any sick, he welcomed them, even the lepers that everyone else shunned.

    When I grew up in the Catholic church I felt the sense of community that this lady wants for her child, regardless of his disability. The article even said they do not know exactly what his mental level is at this time. Everyone deserves the right to worship God without having to be "perfect" to do it. These type of churches are just legalistic. Maybe I never noticed how bad the Catholic church was because I didn't remain in them as an adult. But of course comparing it to the WT, there really is no comparison. The WT is still worse in my opinion. The shunning thing is the most unloving, unchrist like policy anyone can have. It destroys not only families, but people spiritural souls. And for what? Because someone wants to leave the church?

  • Scully
    Scully

    In my opinion you cannot compare the Catholic religion to that of the JW religion because the Catholics do not shun members who decide to stop attending church. Also the JW's do not have a "faith community" in any real sense. They belong to a legalistic cult of mainstream chrisitianity that is more concerned with the members obeying thier rules than with fostering community within its ranks.

    So NO I would not feel the same way about this if it were a mentally challenged jw kid. That is my opinion as a mainstream christian who also grew up in the Catholic church and was a JW for a decade. I am viewing this from my experience on all sides of the issue. While You are also entitled to your opinions you must know you and I will never agree on this one.

    Lil,

    I'm sure you'll agree with me that JWs mis-use the rite of baptism - and they do use it as an inclusionary tool to get individuals to join or "belong" to the cult group. The mind-control tactics play on the sense of belonging that all individuals want - the sense of belonging that is an integral part of the human experience. I think you'll also agree with me that it is a bait-and-switch tactic whereby individuals who become baptized are thereby enslaved / shackled to the group and there is no way out unless they are prepared for the social and emotional ramifications that ensue with shunning.

    To me, it is an issue of the capacity to consent. Legally speaking, some mentally challenged persons do not have the capacity to consent, because they do not comprehend the implied contracts involved in things like taking out a loan at the bank, engaging in sexual activity, and committing to a belief system (to name a few) - all things whereby the person would be at high risk of being taken advantage of by persons who do not have their best interests at heart, but who are seeking their own advantage over someone who will never be their equal. That's why I feel it is unethical, even in cases where the individual wishes to (or is encouraged by their relatives to) submit to these activities.

    There's nothing wrong with us agreeing to disagree on the matter.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit